2058 thumbs up

Help the UN feed people by playing a game Go to freerice.com For every correct answer in the game, rice is donated to hungry people It's FREE, fun, and educational.  To feed animals for free, go to http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com/clickToGive.  "What does it profit a man to gain the world if he loses his soul?"

Is a wrong answer better than no answer?

Is a wrong answer better than no answer?

Would you like to answer or comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).
Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 

Best Answer

 
170 thumbs up

A man who carries a cat by the tail learns something he can learn in no other way

Mark Twain 

Difficult to answer...

I think I would prefer to know that someone has actually taken the time and effort to answer my question, even if there is a chance that that answer was not a 100% accurate. However, it's probably really a matter of personal preference.

What do you think? 


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to profitbob's question
Rated as
Best Answer
0
10

Helpful?

line
line
line


 

All Answers

Order by
 
5547 thumbs up

Love is the battery of life....

Hi,
Sure the answer is not intended to be wrong.... while giving the answer the person is sure that he / she is giving a good / honest / correct answer.....  only later it appears to be wrong....   It happend to me several times, I felt bad.....  In that case the best thing to do is pleed guilty (addmit) and appologize.   I have no doubts: Beter answer than ignore (taking into account that some of your answers might be wrong). I think I read all your answers and you are 99.99% right (and smart) so don't hesitate to answer and help others with your GR8 answers. 
Best personal regards,


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to profitbob's question
Rated as
Best Answer
0
10

Helpful?

line
line
line



 
451 thumbs up

A wrong answer is worse than no answer because it sends the questioner in the wrong direction while no answer gives him/her the chance to ask someone else and get the correct answer.


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to profitbob's question
Rated as
#8 out of 21
0
6

Helpful?

line
line
line



 
2058 thumbs up

Help the UN feed people by playing a game Go to freerice.com For every correct answer in the game, rice is donated to hungry people It's FREE, fun, and educational.  To feed animals for free, go to http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com/clickToGive.  "What does it profit a man to gain the world if he loses his soul?"

Neta, don't you know me well enough yet to know not ask what I think?  That can start an unending letter.  Everybody has a valid point in answer to this question.  That is one of the reasons I asked it.  For this question there is no wrong answer, only incomplete ones, and none could be complete.  The issue is too complex.

    I answer many questions that if I were wrong, the questioner would possibly die.  I'm glad OronD thinks I'm 99.99% right (I would put that a little lower, but I ask the asker questions so I'm not guessing too much).  So on one hand, a wrong answer could be fatal, or injurious, or cause needlessly destruction of personal or public property (remember the discussion about employees and safety equipment?).  Harryvan also says that people could give up looking for the right answer, which could have serious consequences in many ways.

On the other hand, some people ask questions, not so much for the answers, but to have some human contact in a world that counts them as a cipher.  A cog in the machine that is totally replaceable and has little value.  For them, any answer is better than none at all.  It means, "I hear you and someone cares".

On the other hand, look at all the questions that come from the AOL forum on weight loss "How to lose ten pounds in a week", or something like that. These people are looking for affirmation of a mistaken notion.  Giving them the answer to how to lose ten pounds would be injurious to their health, yet correct.  The advice I give them, when I answer, is proper as regards their health, but wrong in that non of my solutions (except the surgical ones) tell them what they want to know.

On the other hand, many of the questioners are emotionally disturbed or in an abusive relationship, or facing some other crisis where the wrong answer could exacerbate their problem.  Giving them advice on how to deal with this problem themselves could be worse then no advice.  When I know I can't help from here, I try to help them connect with people in their area that can really help to deal with their problem.   But not knowing what country they are in, their culture, and many other things, of course my answer lacks specifics in many cases.  It may be that the person I recommend them to is a person that can inflict even more harm (since I sometimes tell people to consult with a doctor or policeman, and in my country, sometimes that can have very bad unintended consequences).

So, I see a lot of gray in the answer, and no black and white.  That is why I asked the question.  I wanted other people to show me more shades of gray.   I didn't even touch on the spiritual issues that people ask about that I answer, and the ones I ignore.  Plus, I always can use a little affirmation now and then, and I have gotten that from the answers, too.

 


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to Neta's answer
Rated as
Best Answer
0
10

Helpful?

line
line
line



 
40 thumbs up

even though the sun is so powerful there is always half of the earth that is not lit up.

i would rather my question be answered a million times and be wrong than to have no one answer b/c then i think that no on ehas heard me.  and i hate when no one answers my questions.


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to profitbob's question
Rated as
#5 out of 21
0
8

Helpful?

line
line
line



 
396 thumbs up

"They will make war against the Lamb, but the lamb will overcome them because he is Lord of lords and King of kings- and with him will be his called, chosen and faithful followers." Revelations 17

I have learned that No, the wrong answer is not better than No answer at all!.. especially here with Yedda!  (which I love by the way)!.. However, if you give an answer someone doesn't like.. (maybe simply doesn't want to hear), they'll give you a Thumbs Down right?  And that's fine, but then, by them doing that it takes away from your Thumbs up..the answers that actually did help someone.  It just doesn't seem right!! Doesn't seem fair!!  I want to be able to keep all my Thumbs up, reguardless of some other answer someone didn't like a week later!!  I'm hurt!!  Gimmy my Thumbs ups back!! Yell   LOL!


Posted 3 months ago ( permalink )
In reply to profitbob's question