• Answers
  • Web

Family is the best thing in life.

Has anyone tried the cookie diet?

Has anyone tried the cookie diet? From what I understand of it, a person can eat 6 cookies a day and a low calorie dinner (totaling 800 calories a day). It sounds like it could work but is this just a quick fix?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 

Best Answer

 
50 helpful answers

If you use more calories than you put in you'll lose weight. That's the simple equation that applies to healthy people. The cookie diet is no different but I would stay away from diets that give you these types of solutions. Try getting on a diet that'll hold long term.

Helpful?(3)
Rated as Best Answer

 

All Answers
Order by

 
881 helpful answers

The journey to an improved lifestyle begins with the first step.

Confident Lifestyle 

Confident Lifestyle Blog 

Tiptop Server 

 

No I have not tried it and here is why. Please pay extra attention to what I put in bold italics and underlined.

The total calorie count of the diet comes out to approximately 800 calories per day, and total carbohydrate intake is about 70 grams per day, making Siegal's program an extremely low-calorie, low carbohydrate diet.

What is not as frequently mentioned is that reportedly, as many as 60 percent of patients on the Cookie Diet are also prescribed appetite suppressant drugs, and another 25 percent are prescribed thyroid hormones.

The cookies, which Siegal claims have amino acids with appetite suppressant properties, are available in chocolate, raisin or coconut flavors, but even Siegal admits that they don't taste very good. Don't look for them on your local store shelves anytime soon, however. Siegal's cookies are available only to patients at his weight loss clinics (five are in Florida, and one is in Montreal), as part of his estimated $400 a month weight loss treatment program.

Some weight loss experts say that any diet that provides only 800 calories a day is bound to work, but at what price? Experts say that the diet provides far too few calories to maintain health and energy, and is seriously lacking in fruits and vegetables. (1 cup a day of vegetables doesn't make a dent in the recommendation that we eat 5-9 servings a day of vegetables and fruit). Others have alleged that the Cookie Diet doesn't provide sufficient vitamins, minerals, and fiber. Even Siegal admits that the Cookie Diet is not meant to be used for long periods of time. Many diet experts say that once people resume normal eating habits, they will regain the weight lost on drastic diets like this one.

So please if you want to diet, just make a lifestyle change and start eating a sensible diet.

Good luck and best wishes. 

 
1 helpful answer

yes it is a quick fix, but if you can then eat correctly and throw in some exercise you can stay at your weight. I did it almost two years ago and although I've put on about 5lbs  of the almost 30 lost, I'm now very careful of what I eat. Good luck to you!

 
1 helpful answer

I have been on the Smart for Life version of the cookie diet for five weeks.  I've lost 24 pounds.  The cookies are good, and you eat a dinner consisting of six ounces of lean protein and two servings of vegetables.  So it's basically a calorie counting diet.  You consume about 850 calories per day, weigh in once a week and meet with the doctor once a month.  I've tried pretty much everything and general diet and exercise worked for my first 65 pound loss, but then I hit a platue and started the cookies.  Email me if you have questions.  Good luck and let me know if you try it.   

lookeyherey@yahoo.com
Helpful?(3)
Rated as Best Answer
 

Yes!!! I have tried it and it is wonderful.

I have a bunch of friends who have also been using the products and they are completely transformed.  The cookies keep you filled up all day and at night, you get to eat a regular dinner.  I am not hungry at all and I am already losing weight!!!

 

I'm on Smart For Life Weight Managment's program.

It's not 800 calories. My program is 1200 calories. Each cookie contains 105 calories and I eat a healthy dinner at night. It's plenty of food.

I ordered my cookies at  www.cookiedoctor.com  and they were mailed right to me with no extra charges. 

 

You have to make sure you buy the right cookies because there are some other people selling online.  Be sure you go to www.cookiedoctor.com

These are better tasting than some of the others that are sold online.

They use all natural ingredients- even tripple filtered water!

 

My friends who are on the program like the fact that they can store the cookies in the freezer and use them as needed.  You know, sometimes after you have lost the weight, you can fall off - and gain some weight back with any program.  This program makes it easy to just get back on for a few days and slim down.

 

 

what cookies and shakes taste the best? Or does it all take like cardboard? I am real serious about starting the program, I do everything from eating correctly, and working out when I have time and after 2 children... nothing is working...ughh. Thanx for your help.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for rebecca.young? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

How long does it takes untill you see results?

how long does it takes untill you see results?
Submitted by dbestar   3 months ago.
  • viewed 1298 times
Last answer posted 29 days ago by Diet GURU


Q:

Calorie Control The Key To Weight Loss

If you are looking for the next miracle pill that will “shed the pounds forever” then you might as well stop reading now because ...
Submitted by lose belly fat   6 months ago.
  • viewed 607 times
Last answer posted 2 months ago by cess06



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Is Raw Cookie Dough Food ?

A popular stand alone food item in the US. Why do people want to eat raw cookie dough ? Is it even The source of the e coli in the cookie dough that sickened dozens of people in a number of States The source of the e coli in the cookie dough that sickened dozens of people in a number of States has not been identified...

I need help with my new life style changes!! Weight Loss!!

To five days a week and NOTHING!! Is there anything I can do to help "jump-start" my weight loss?? I have realized that I have let my health go for so long that I am not far from some severe health issues I've done scads of research lately due to a variety of health problems surfacing with several of my

halloween weight loss challenge 10/1

Be "wicked hot" for halloween! (THIS IS THE FORMER LABOR DAY, 4TH OF JULY, EASTER AND CHRISTMAS WEIGHT LOSS CHALLENGE...) EVERYONE IS WELCOME TO JOIN THIS CHALLENGE; JUST START CHATTING! Anyone can start halloween is 4 1/2 weeks (or 32 days) away! If we choose to lose 1-2 pounds per week, we should be "wicked hot" for halloween...
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2010, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License