Personalize Yedda, (And make Danny Happy)
People ask & answer about almost everything. Tell us what you're interested in... So we can personalize Yedda especially for you
I'm interested in:

Should the states be more forceful in expressing ...

Should the states be more forceful in expressing their rights to Sovereignty after the way that federal government has acted recently.


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

5 Posted Answers
Order by

 
Steve
(deleted account)


The doctrine of states' rights was violated, not "recently," but consistently over the last eight years. 


It began after Election Day 2000. The Florida Supreme Court unanimously called for a recount of the state's votes


Republicans appealed to the US Supreme Court which ordered the state of Florida to STOP COUNTING THE VOTES. Two of the Justices who overruled Florida were appointed to their posts by George W. Bush's own father. Now what could be a more stunning interference with states' rights?


But it goes further. President George W. Bush ignoring pleas of state governors sent national guard units into Iraq depriving the states of the emergency services these guards provide.


How many more people could have been rescued in New Orleans had the state militia had a full presence there? How many cities find themselves with fewer law enforcement officers and firefighters because those who belong to guard units were mobilized and sent overseas? 


In Florida you had courts following state law. A husband had the right to remove his brain-dead wife from the treatment that kept her body alive. President Bush had Congress rush through legislation which violated any doctrine of reserved powers by granting federal courts jurisdiction. Thankfully, the federal judges deferred to the state of Florida.


When voters in California voted to approve the use of marijuana to those patience undergoing the rigors of chemotherapy, the Bush Administration announced it would indict and prosecute any doctor who participated in the program.


When same sex marriage was sanctioned by state legislatures or recognized by state courts, it was the Bush administration which called for a Constitutional Amendment to deprive the states of this authority.


President Obama has been rushing federal funds to states to enable them to retain law enforcement officers, firefighters, and teachers who might otherwise have been laid off.


Federal stimulus spending will transfer the costs of rebuilding roads, bridges, and tunnels to the federal government, relieving the hard-pressed states of this burden. 


By saving thousands of jobs through stimulus packages and bail-outs, the Obama Administration has come to the rescue of states who would simultaneously face reduced income tax revenues and greater spending to cover unemployment claims.

While the rights of states have been under assault by the Bush Administration, it is the Obama Administration which is restoring the balance. 

 

Posted 2009-07-02T13:28:40Z
Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer
 
1 helpful answer

after reading your statement I would have to ask the question of why if Obama were restoring the balance of states powers back to the states then why did he tell those same states that they couldnt use the stimulus monies that they would recieve in a way that they saw fit for the betterment of  their states. those same bounds were oversteped when that very right was taken away. It cant be wrong for 1 administration and right for another.

Posted 2009-07-03T05:12:39Z
 
Steve
(deleted account)

One of the greatest abuses of the federal government against the states can be seen in unfunded mandates, that is when the US government requires states to do something (for example, add elevators in all multi-level public schools) without providing adequate funding to get the task done.

What we have here is precisely the opposite. Congress has mandated that certain things be accomplished and is providing the states with the funds to accomplish those tasks.

Consider this issue on a local level. If a state legislature sends a town money with instructions to repair the local sewer, should that town be able divert those funds to build a new bridge? If so, state government becomes a joke.

In some matters (family law, educational requirements, patients' rights, etc.), the states should be as individual as the fingers on your hand.

But on other matters, matters that affect the entire nation (the national highway system, the electronic grid, air pollution, unemployment, etc.), the states must be as coordinated as the fingers that make a fist.

If a state legislature authorizes money be spent for a specific purpose, the Governor can't redirect those funds for something else or refuse to spend the money.  This would most likely result in the Governor's impeachment.

It would be illogical to assert that while the Governor must follow the state legislature's instructions regarding state funds, he or she should be free to ignore Congress's instructions regarding federal funds.

 

Posted 2009-07-03T10:43:21Z
 
60 helpful answers

Yes, but it will have to be in a conservative state. Unfortunately,  I'm in the weanie state of California, led by the "girlie-man", himself (who  isn't really a Replublican).

Posted 2009-07-05T19:45:40Z
stevor was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
21 helpful answers

Courteous, yet lively debate, keeps the cobwebs from forming and misinformation as well.

Why was it OK while Bush was in office????

Posted 2009-07-07T21:07:35Z
niteowlett was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for hlnwlf1? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT

More AOL News Stories

Obama's Bow in Japan Enrages Critics

Bloggers are still buzzing about the way President Obama greeted Japan's Emperor Akihito in Tokyo this weekend. His defenders say Obama's deep bow was in keeping with protocol while his critics call it a sign of weakness. Regardless of the political signals, experts on bowing say Obama botched it.

Cops Search for Missing 5-Year-Old

The location and fate of a 5-year-old girl reported missing by her mother was unknown even after authorities charged the mother with human trafficking and other offenses.

Charities May Not Have a Happy Holiday

American charities have weathered a significant drop in giving this year, and while they're hoping for a holiday miracle, a recent survey shows they will probably see a decrease in year-end generosity.

Palin's Way of Talkin' Dissected

When Sarah Palin burst onto the national political stage, there was a lot of talk about her distinctive way of talkin', you betcha. Heck, she grew up in Alaska but doggone it, why did she talk like someone from the movie "Fargo"? Three linguists tackled the conundrum in a research article to be published next month.

Police: Chicago School Official Killed Self

A body pulled from the Chicago River early this morning is believed to be that of Michael Scott, president of the Chicago School Board, according to local media reports.

Doctors Operate on Conjoined Twins

A team of Australian surgeons were working Monday on a delicate and complicated surgery to separate twin sisters who are joined at the top of the head.

Climate Blamed for Swarming Jellyfish

Scientists believe climate change — the warming of oceans — has allowed some of the almost 2,000 jellyfish species to expand their ranges, appear earlier in the year and increase overall numbers, much as warming has helped ticks, bark beetles and other pests to spread to new latitudes.

Drilling for Scotch Whisky in Antarctica

A beverage company has asked a team to drill through Antarctica's ice for a lost cache of some vintage Scotch whiskey that has been on the rocks since a century ago, when it was shipped by British polar explorer Sir Ernest Shackleton as part of his abandoned 1909 expedition

Study Raises Concerns on Heart Drugs

A new study raises fresh concerns about Zetia and its cousin, Vytorin _ drugs still taken by millions of Americans to lower cholesterol, despite questions raised last year about how well they work.

JFK's Last Autograph Sold for Big Bucks

What could be the last autograph signed by President Kennedy was sold recently at an auction of items linked to his assassination in Texas. Kennedy reportedly signed the front page of the Dallas Morning News, which contained a photo of him and the first lady and a preview of their arrival that day in Dallas.
» More...
Powered by
ADVERTISEMENT
AOL News Q&A is powered by Yedda an AOL Company
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners