Teach yourself by experiences !!!

Should my sister give a divorce or not..

Living happily as a bachelor, i have something which is troubling me for the past few years.

We are based in India and we are of orthodox hindus.

My sister (we will call her ABC), married the guy she loved...her life went on wonderful for nearly 5-6 years, and had 2 children.

My brother-in-law (lets call him XYZ), was sweet and loving husband, and they were happy.

XYZ, was in regular touch with a girl who is a relative of us. Later that became physical, eventhough that girl was in her teens. The relationship went on for some time, when ABC caught them "in action", and ABC made a scene and sent out this girl. From that day on their married life became like a ship in mid storm.

We brothers came to know of how intimate XYZ and the other girl was through their chats in HOT****L. XYZ, had left the username and password on his shelf and ABC found something fishy on that and gave us the details, which proved more sexual than a porno movie (that girl is still in her teens).

Then XYZ & ABC moved out of that town and settled in a city (the distance of that girl's location is around 26hrs by train). ABC was a bit happy on this and this happiness did not stay for long. He started making small small reasons to go back to that town, and meet this girl.

When ABC started questioning this, XYZ physically abused her by pulling her pubic hair, tieing her up, kicking her, slapping her.... (all this only after the children went to sleep) ABC did not tell much to us about XYZ's abuse. When it went out of control, she cameback to us with the kids like a wounded soldier, scars on her face and heart.

This all happend about 4 years earlier.

Presently, this XYZ's final settlement from defence services (on retirement) is being held, as ABC has asked the court to do so, and ABC has not given him a divorce till date, eventhough he started to plead. Once he gets a official divorce, he could verywell spoil another girl's life.

After you guys learning about all the story....my question is.

Should she now give him a divorce and take care of the kids, as i'm supporting her and she is self employed?

or should she keep fighting (wasting money and energy) against XYZ?.

For your info, i's single (43 yrs old) and presently supporting ABC and her kids. After separation, ABC was working in the automobile industry and presently is a working partner of a small establishment.

Sorry for the long question....anyway you need a preface for a sad story...


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

5 Posted Answers
Order by

 
4 helpful answers

She should divorce the idiot and take him for all she can get. He has had 4 years to get his act straight and failed to do so. He is the worst sort of scum. In our family the brothers would have taken care of him the first time he hit her. A marriage license is a license to love, not hit. Religion has nothing to do with this. An old saying in our family is this "A son is a son until he takes a wife, but a daughter is a daughter all of her life." The girls father should have taken care of the matter. If the father is dead or otherwise not able to do so, it fall to he eldest son.  

 
4552 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi, ------ What's the question ?, she MUST give him a divorce NOW..... several years too late.  Nothing will help, he is a cheater, has no morals, and loves that other girl.  I wonder why are you in doubt...... it's clear like the sun....... ----------- Best regards,

 

 
841 helpful answers

     S.N.O.T.S.

Snotsworth's Fair Lady Snots'quus

May The Horse Be With You !

OronD & Retired spook , Thumbs Up !  

Troubled Brother ,  What is the question is right , there is no question .  She must fill for divorce immediately .   Her husband not only is an adultrous , he is an abuser and could very well seriously injure or kill your sister .  This is NO WAY for those children to be raised .  Urge your sister to protect her children and herself by filling for divorce .  Your brother in law is a dangerous man .

Helpful?(3)
Rated as Best Answer
 

Teach yourself by experiences !!!

Thank you "Retired spook" & "OronD"...for your comments....

As "Retired Spook" rightly said, we brothers would have kicked that bastard and make him repentful throughout his life....but my sister was not ready for anything and was expecting him to comeback out from the lust. Also, we came to know about the physical abuse only on the later stages.

As "orond" suggested....giving a divorce and living "life" was the suggestion i too have been insisting. The main idea of this question i have raised in the net is becuase i can show the replies from you people and make her understand.

"Equus"....we knew this bastard is a dangerous man and we are careful too...

 

Posted 2009-06-08T07:00:04Z
 
18 helpful answers

Natural and organic fertility and women products all the way! Lady-Comp and Today Sponge rocks my world! FREE 1 BOX of Natacare product for every Lady-Comp purchase! FREE DELIVERY for US customers!

A divorce has been long overdue. Yo need to keep your sister and her children away from this guy.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Troubled Brother? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Need a relationship counselors help on this one

Thanks for all the responses, this is young entreprenuer. It's now been over a year since I broke up with my ex. Since then, I ...
Submitted by YoungEntrepreneur   1 year ago.
  • viewed 2158 times
Last answer posted 16 days ago by Francis Wakhisi
Asked about "Get personal advice"


Q:

I need some interpersonal family relationships ...

I need some interpersonal family relationships information. Im trying my best to find some sort of information on the web but i'm ...
Submitted by snake   1 year ago.
  • viewed 452 times
Last answer posted 1 month ago by hector vasquez


Q:

Relationship with married man

i have been seeing a married man for 1year he decided to leave his wife which he as done i found out he was having sex with her ...
Submitted by tlc   2 months ago.
  • viewed 733 times
Last answer posted 2 days ago by Mollie Bevan
Asked about "Relationships"



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Psychiatry therapy in Family Medicine | Family Medicine

For psychotherapy and treatment. Since family physicians treat depression, bipolar etc via medications and with counseling, can Family physicians use cpt code for psychotherapy and treatment for patients Quote: : can Family physicians use cpt code for psychotherapy and treatment for patients

Oddish Family, Sunkern Family, Budew Family, or Cherubi Family?

Well I voted and I chose the Oddish family. I just love bellosom. So cute with its hula skirt like it is a close second with Cherrim.I prefer the Oddish family, I like all the stages, I always As the question goes, which grass-type do you prefer; The original mandrake/rafflasia pokemon that has a cross-evolution?...

another family murdered - The Gee Family

Wow! I guess police have no idea if this was a stranger or extended family that did it. How scary.5 family members found slain in central Illinois By CHRISTOPHER WILLS, Associated Press Writer http://www.pantagraph.com/news/local...cc4c03286.html
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License