Originated from
AOL Search

Engineering forum Who wants to fight city hall ...

engineering forum Who wants to fight city hall? The great city of XXXCa is requiring 57,680 pound of uplift constraint (and 115360 pounds of load bearing capacity for...wait for it...a patio cover. This is an open lattice cross beam arbor. The entire structure weighs in at something under 5,000 pounds. Is anyone (some bored aero engineer maybe) up to calculating the possible up lift from say a 70 mph wind. I have a Solid Works drawing if you are interested. I'd really like some number for my upcoming meeting with "building & safety". Can you believe no one in the city office including the building "inspector" is an engineer?   Jim jgvapfc@aol.com


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

2 Posted Answers
Order by

 
5 helpful answers

We all know what the speed of light is, however, I wonder, what is the speed of dark?

WOW, 29 tons of uplift prevention, and 58 tons of load bearing capacity. Of course , you don't mention the dimensions of the patio in order to compute bearing load or uplift per square foot. However, I just can't imagine what dimensions would require these numbers. California must be unique, or the town building inspectors must be pure stupid. If there is no building engineer, how can they even dispute your plans?

Posted 2009-10-31T19:53:13Z
Jerry was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 

Building departments do not hire engineers because they cost too much.  So they need to play "cya" and get a professional civil engineer to sign off on your design.  It seems to me your choices are find a friendly civil engineer who will sign it for you for a hundred bucks or so or go to the library and get the latest copy of the Uniform Building Code which the bible for city types.  This will put you on a level playing field with city hall.  Building inspectors generally do not know their butt from six bitts they only know what they read in the Building Code.  They are NOT construction inspectors, they are compliance inspectors.  Do not let them intimidate you.  Have them show you in the UBC where they got their figures and take it from there.  I am a retired engineer, construction manager, and construction inspector and I hold city building inspectors in great disdain.  Good luck.

Posted 2009-11-01T19:00:47Z
Herman was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for JimVM? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Posts in Forums

How important is it to understand the history of science in the...

One of the electives I took in college was a history of science course. It ended up being way to understand science. Yes, the reason being is to gain a better understanding of the methods

possibly the coolest science tattoo i have seen yet : science

Interested in seeing more of that subject matter, ifyouknowwhatimean. Is it Texan or Afghan science Interested in seeing more of that subject matter, ifyouknowwhatimean. Is it Texan or Afghan science? There's a difference...

Good music and fun science by They Might Be Giants, wish i had it like this...

That science and religion are wholly separate entities Upvote for schizophrenia. Songs so simple &feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhuMLpdnOjY Science isn't real; it's just a theory
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT

More AOL News Stories

Investigation Begins Into Deadly Power...

All workers are accounted for after Sunday's explosion in Middletown, Conn., which killed five and injured at least 12.

Iran Says It Will Go Ahead With Nuclear...

The U.S., France and Russia call for tougher sanctions against Iran, which says it will begin enriching its uranium to a higher level to power a medical reactor, fueling fears that Tehran aims to produce nuclear weapons.

The Filter: Soldier Accused of...

AOL News' close read of this morning's news roundups also includes the latest scuttlebutt on what the Times has dug up on New York's governor.

Gov. Paterson Meets With Lawmakers Over...

New York's governor meets with party leaders about his re-election plans as rumors swirl over an expected New York Times story.

Saints Upset Colts to Win First Super Bowl

The New Orleans Saints bask in victory after overtaking the highly-favored Indianapolis Colts to nab the team's first Super Bowl win. Plus: Letterman, Leno Pair Up in Ad

'I Would' Run for President, Sarah Palin...

She leaves the door open for a 2012 White House bid and accuses President Obama of acting like he wants Americans to "shut up."

Americans Jailed in Haiti Send Disturbing...

One of the Baptist missionaries charged with kidnapping Haitian children slips a note to a reporter. "We fear for our lives," it says. Plus: Haiti's Newborns Face Hardships
» More...
Powered by
ADVERTISEMENT
AOL News Q&A is powered by Yedda an AOL Company
Copyright © 2006-2010, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners
Latest news, weather, health, business, sports, science, money, entertainment, world news, elections, weird news and more.