You love them both. You love them all.
Free love is the freedom to express love whenever and to whomever you wish. Love is like air. It comes in abundance. No shortage. Like smiles. One attracts more.
don't stop yourself from loving someone just because of this and that. dont make rules about love. that is just cutting yourself short. By the looks of your happy smile - you spread love around you, everybody loves you, and you are free to love us all back.