Personalize Yedda, (And make Danny Happy)
People ask & answer about almost everything. Tell us what you're interested in... So we can personalize Yedda especially for you
I'm interested in:
Originated from
Mike Marcus's Profile

Rejected slogan #235:

Yedda - a brain the size of a planet.

Wide angle lens

I am considering getting a wide-angle lens for my Canon 350D.

I already own a 50mm and a 18-200mm.

What are the important considerations when choosing a wide angle lens? Should I go as wide as 10mm? Prime or not? Any specific recommended models?

Thanks!

Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 

Best Answer

 
865 helpful answers

Just remember that a wide angle lens is just that. It allows you to get that much more into your frame but the cost is that there is distortion. You will find that the verticals at the edges are not purely vertical with the tops angled out and the bottoms angled in.

Posted 2007-07-25T18:20:54Z
Helpful?(4)
Rated as Best Answer

 

All Answers
Order by

 
2 helpful answers

i have a tokina 12-24 and im happy with it. The build quality is great but it has a fair amount of chromatic abberation. I guess that the main thing is that Im just not into the wide angle asthetic so i cant comment on it like i could on a nice portrait lens. You definately need a proper flash though. The on-camera unit leaves a massive shadow.

You will find yourself using fill flash much more than expected with a very wide lens.

I think i would have been just as happy with a prime.

Posted 2007-07-26T01:39:18Z
Mike Marcus was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(4)
Rated as Best Answer
 
48 helpful answers

First of all, your options for wide angle zooms are:

  • Canon EF-S 10-22mm f/3.5-4.5 USM - 680$
  • Sigma 10-20mm F4-5.6 EX DC HSM - 460$
  • Sigma 12-24mm F4-5.6 EX DG ASPHERICAL/ HSM - 600$
  • Tamron SP AF11-18MM F/4.5-5.6 Di II LD Aspherical (IF) - 530$
  • Tokina AT-X 124 AF PRO DX (12-24mm) - 480$

you should take into account that canon ef-s, sigma dc, tamron Di and tokina dx are designed especially for APS-C size sensors (and for your EF-S mount on the 350D).

That means that you'll have considerably more distortion if you ever place one of these on a full frame body (if you'll ever switch to the 1D or 5D for example).

These lenses cost around 500US$ (give or take a 100$), and this is a lot of money for lenses you won't be able to use on your next cam.

On the other hand, most DSLRs made today have a smaller than full frame sensors, so even if you upgrade to a 30D or smthng like that, you won't have a problem.

All canon wide angle primes are for the EF mount, and not EF-S, all sigma's primes are DG and not DC, tamron's prime is not a Di and tokina have no wide angle prime at all.

By getting your self a prime, you avoid the dilemma above.

Posted 2007-08-04T07:42:49Z
Helpful?(4)
Rated as Best Answer
 
111 helpful answers

Rejected slogan #235:

Yedda - a brain the size of a planet.

Thanks Rock, it's this distortion that I am looking for :)

Posted 2007-08-06T06:48:52Z
 
111 helpful answers

Rejected slogan #235:

Yedda - a brain the size of a planet.

Thanks for the info Mike. Is there any way to overcome the shadow problem without a flash? An extension tube perhaps?

 
2 helpful answers

no, an extension tube will just stop you focusing at infinity and obscure the flash more. The shadow is cased by the lens blocking the light from the flash. The solution is to move the flash away from the camera body (either higher than the cameras built in flash or to the side with a bracket)

I am using fill flash a lot becuase I feel that there is a need to provide a separaration between the FG and BG on very wide shots. It could just be my asthetic though.

Posted 2007-08-06T09:13:35Z
Mike Marcus was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
111 helpful answers

Rejected slogan #235:

Yedda - a brain the size of a planet.

I ended up getting the Canon EF-S 10-22mm f/3.5-4.5 USM. I am going to put it to a real test later today, and will report on my findings :)

Thank you all for the information & helpful advice!

Posted 2007-08-16T12:33:44Z
 
111 helpful answers

Rejected slogan #235:

Yedda - a brain the size of a planet.

To follow up on my promise from many months ago to report my findings -

I love this lens.

It get some getting used to, with its strange distortion effects, but once you get the hang of it, it's addictive.

I love what it does to the human body when shot from the right angles.  

My only frustration is that I got the EF-S one and not the EF one, so I can't really use it with Canon 5D or 1D.

Some recent samples: 

Up Dublin Romance The nicest violin player ever

Posted 2007-12-18T18:04:50Z
 
1 helpful answer

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Yaniv? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Canon Wide Angle Lens - Options?

What do you recommend for a wide angle lens for a Canon Rebel xTI? Or is there another less expensive lens that will do about the ...
Submitted by sgruning   2 years ago.
  • viewed 3571 times
Last answer posted 2 years ago by sectorsix


Q:

Sigma 18-200 for Canon 350D?

I am cosidering getting a Sigma 18-200 lens for my Canon 350D. Other options are of course the Tamron and the Canon 18-200. The ...
Submitted by Yaniv   4 years ago.
  • viewed 3086 times
Last answer posted 1 year ago by Bazilio


Q:

Walkaround lens

I need a walk around lens for my EOS 350D (a.k.a Digital Rebel XT). I have the kit lens (Canon EF-S 18-55 f/3.5-5.6), a telephoto ...
Submitted by gkamin   3 years ago.
  • viewed 1125 times
Last answer posted 3 years ago by olegshilovitsky



» More...

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
AOL Health Q&A is powered by Yedda an AOL Company
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners