Personalize Yedda, (And make Danny Happy)
People ask & answer about almost everything. Tell us what you're interested in... So we can personalize Yedda especially for you
I'm interested in:

Is there a god?

Is there a god?

And if so, who or what is god?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

108 Posted Answers
Order by

 
30 helpful answers

Wow, that's quite a question.

I'm guessing you realise providing a full answer to this question is impossible. Greater men have tried and failed.

Our perceptions and empirical sciences states there is no proof either way. Psychological theory states that God comes hand in hand with Consciousness, some sort of defense mechanism of a primitive mind trying to make sense of it all, to provide Meaning. Brain scans have shown a particular region of the brain that "awakens" when people have spiritual experiences, nicknamed the "God Spot", almost as if God created us with a biological facility for belief.

And on the other hand, we have religion and faith, practiced by about 99 percent of the world's population, in some way or another. It is kind of hard to argue that such a large portion of the world is suffering from some sort of delusion. 

And God itself, how do you define God? Are you speaking of an all powerful being that created our world and continues to govern it? Or just an intelligent set of governing rules that apply to the universe, a higher force? 

My opinion? I do not think humanity needs a God figure in order to be spiritual. This is the last step before fully realising we are nothing more than a mass of smart molecules, but that doesn't mean we aren't spiritual. Transcedence is possible without an God figure.

This shouldn't stop at a mere question/answer. This should continue into a debate.  

Posted 2006-09-01T01:10:03Z
TalSh was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(14)
Rated as Best Answer
 
2 helpful answers

TalSh's answer was a good one. Respectful and moving in the right direction.

I'd go further though and state categorically that there is no god. Why?

Scientific: Occam's razor - god is a an additional complication and un-necessary extension to the assumptions required to explain the world as we find it.

Moral: Belief in god has been the single greatest cause of human misery in the world. Any god worth the name would be ashamed to exist.u

Psychological: Every issolated tribe has felt the need to invent god as TalSh says. But this points to the psychological human need for authority and for meaning. The fact that the forms of these invetions of god are as diverse as the inventors supports a view that god does not exist.

Logical: God is the answer to the question "what is the meaning of life". But that question makes no sense. Meaning is a human construct. Why should life have meaning? If you insist that it does have meaning, then god is the only answer. The question pre-supposes the answer.

Subjective Reality: God does exist. We all have a part of our inner being that is pure, sane to whom we turn in crisis. Each of us has his own god, who is omnipotent in our own lives. But let's not make the mistake of externalising this entity and then start forcing others to believe in him. Along this road lies George Bush.

Posted 2006-09-01T09:34:14Z
Helpful?(14)
Rated as Best Answer
 
4 helpful answers

Yes, God exists.

Goodness, 384 views of this question so far, and I’m the first one to say it?

I can’t prove it to you, but I believe in God, and Jesus Christ, the Son of God.

It’s true many horrible things have been done in the name of religion.  It’s true many people would prefer to live in a world free of God.  It’s also true that beautiful things have been done in the name of religion (many religions).  And it’s true that many people crave God’s grace.

God Bless You!

Posted 2006-09-05T14:20:17Z
 
Jim
5 helpful answers

Yes, there is.  Submit the following for your consideration.

WHY SOME MEN BELIEVE IN GODScientist-inventor Thomas Edison, when asked his view about whether there is a God, replied: “After years of watching the processes of nature, I cannot doubt the existence of a Supreme Intelligence. The existence of such a God can, to my mind, almost be proved from chemistry.”Theologian Thomas Aquinas gave reason for belief in the existence of God with a premise common both to the theist and to the atheist, the fact that “some things are in motion.” ‘Motion implies an unmoved Mover; similarly, there must be an uncaused First Cause that possesses in itself the reason for its existence; the existence of creatures whose nonexistence is possible implies the existence of a necessary Creator; the scale of perfections evident in the universe implies the existence of an absolute standard, a perfect Being.’Scientist Sir Isaac Newton had this to say about nature and God: “Whence is it that nature does nothing in vain; and whence arises all that order and beauty which we see in the world? . . . How came the bodies of animals to be contrived with so much art and for what ends were their several parts? Was the eye contrived without skill in optics, or the ear without knowledge of sounds? . . . And these things being rightly despatched, does it not appear from phenomena that there is a being incorporeal, living, intelligent?”Mathematician and chemist John Cleveland Cothran says: “Lord Kelvin, one of the world’s greatest physicists, has made the following significant statement: ‘If you think strongly enough, you will be forced by science to believe in God.’ I must declare myself in full agreement with this statement.” Cothran further states: “The material realm not being able to create itself and its governing laws, the act of creation must have been performed by some nonmaterial agent. . . . Hence our logical and inescapable conclusion is not only that creation occurred but that it was brought about according to the plan and will of a Person endowed with supreme intelligence and knowledge (omniscience), and the power to bring it about and keep it running according to plan (omnipotence). That is to say, we accept unhesitatingly the fact of the existence of ‘the supreme spiritual Being, God, the Creator and Director of the universe,’ mentioned in the beginning. . . . The advances that have occurred in science since Lord Kelvin’s day would enable him to state more emphatically than ever: ‘If you think strongly enough, you will be forced by science to believe in God.’”The existence of radioactive elements establishes a beginning to earth’s creation. The fact that such radioactive elements, which disintegrate over a period of time, are still in existence is incontrovertible evidence that the earth has not always existed, that it did have a beginning. And since no material thing can create itself, and since not even the wisest scientist will argue that the universe created itself out of nothing, all of this points to but one thing—God.Consider the magnificent universe in which we live. Consider our earth and the great variety and complexity of living organisms on it. Could chance or any known natural laws have built them up from inorganic matter? According to Bryant, Lecomte du Nouy, the first scientist to apply mathematical formulae successfully to the statement of biological laws, shows that “the laws of inorganic evolution contradict those of the evolution of life. He gives mathematical formulae to show that inorganic matter acting in accordance with its laws could not have created even a single molecule of protein—let alone a living organism with powers of reproduction. He maintains that only through the intervention of God could the gap have been bridged between the inorganic and the organic.”Not only does science give one reason to believe in God, but it causes one to see the need for a revelation from God about himself. The Bible fills that need. Chemist Roger J. Voskuyl says: “As a scientist, it is more reasonable for me to believe in a Creator than in an eternally existing cosmos. . . . One cannot rightly know God from the natural world alone. The scientist may work for an eternity, but he will never come to know God and all His attributes. . . . Man is but a creature of a Creator; therefore, man cannot learn about God by investigation of His creation alone, but he needs a special revelation. That special revelation is God’s Word, which has been given in the Scriptures.”

The answer as to who he is, provided in his written word, which requires study.

Posted 2008-07-11T21:29:25Z
Helpful?(6)
Rated #4 out of 107
 

Firstly, and not to start a flame war here, but very clearly 99% of the world do not believe in a god.  This is a fiction.  For a start China is communist and therefore wont believe in a god, not mention Japan or in fact anyone practicing Buddhism.

So, is there a god?  It depends what you mean and how you define such a question. 

If you mean, is there a white guy with a beard and a unnatural fixation for Jewish virgins and that you can take a deep breath and relax knowing in firm certainty that by believing one thing or another will set you up for the afterlife?; then no, probably not.

If you mean, some sort of super being that created the Universe (note caps on the U); then nobody knows for sure.  It is possible, but then so if everything you can imagine and quite a lot that you can not.  A great book for examining ideas about this is The Star Maker by Olaf Stapleton or perhaps the free online book "God's Debris" written by the Dilbert author Scott Adams.  They both show that when you get to a "power" of that "size" you could quite easily mistake it for a simple facet of nature or physics.

If however, you want cold hard scientific certainty or rigid philosophical arguments one way or the other, again nope.  Neither science nor Philosophy has successfully argued that there is or is not a god.  That is to say that arguments are in fact put forwards and laws formulated regarding standards of proof etc, but in the end they are only measuring what they know.  Not what they don't.  So here the answer is again "as far as we know" there isn't a God.  Why?  because of the lack of rigid evidence.

Edit for spelling. 

Posted 2006-09-02T15:57:22Z
Basho was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(4)
Rated #5 out of 107
 
9 helpful answers

There is no proof that gods and goddesses exist, and there is no proof that they DON'T exist.

Religious texts authored by humans don't prove the existence of any god(s).

 

Posted 2008-11-13T03:56:39Z
Helpful?(4)
Rated #6 out of 107
 
1 helpful answer

Asking the question if there is a God is analogous to asking, "Does my apple taste good?" You would probably reply, "How would I know?" My response to you would be, "One does not know of such things until he takes a bite for himself." Have you tasted the apple, eGrant? Have you tried to seek God for yourself? If you try hard enough, you will find Him. His name is Jesus and his biography is called the Bible. Try reading the New Testament and psalms and you will probably discover the answer to your question.

Good luck!

Posted 2007-02-22T03:12:46Z
Helpful?(3)
Rated #7 out of 107
 
1 helpful answer

I guess the best anser to this question is:

Do you want there to be a god?

If so there is

If not then there isn't

I hope I helped you

 

Posted 2006-10-05T08:58:01Z
Helpful?(3)
Rated #8 out of 107

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for eGrant? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Life Without God

For those of you who do not believe in God or a Higher Power, to what to you attribute your ability to sustain serenity, peace ...
Submitted by Yada Yada   8 months ago.
  • viewed 125 times
Last answer posted 4 months ago by Veggie-Trunks


Q:

Does God exist?

Does God exist? Why or why not? It's seems more rational to believe he does exist than not. My stance is that he does exist.
Submitted by xtreme_devotion_120   2 years ago.
  • viewed 1137 times
Last answer posted 10 days ago by Kinasgirl


Q:

Which religion is considered having the most ...

Which religion is considered having the most observant believers? Can there be an answer for such a question?
Submitted by Raydan   3 years ago.
  • viewed 1395 times
Last answer posted 1 month ago by Lee



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Religion and Philosophy and Philosophy and Religion

It's fashionable among certain people these days to portray philosophy and religion as embraced ? Religion can offer philosophy on ways to live and Philosophy can offer thoughts on ways to believe... In what way do each of these domains of knowledge intersect one another? All that is gold does not glitter, not all those...

Religion Versus Philosophy

The main difference between philosophy and religion is that the former tends to subject God . Undoubtedly religion demands intellectual affirmation, but this is not the goal. As Iqbal put " philosophies. Why because they dare to think?? Philosophy complements religion rather than oppose

Philosophy/religion

My question is when does philosophy turn into a religion , after all is is a system of beliefs and sometimes, for some people it is faith to the exclusion of reason. Whereas Philosophy could Quote: : My question is when does philosophy turn into a religion , after all is is a system
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License