• Answers
  • Web

Is using a little spanking while raising a child ...

Is using  a little spanking while raising a child proven as harming? Does it damage his development?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 

Best Answer

 
13 helpful answers

Thank you for the clarification.

I still feel that you're better advised to use other means than spanking. While most people who have been spanked haven't suffered lasting damage, physical or emotional, corporal punishment is generally considered a poor means of discipline by most parents and child development consultants today. 

Posted 2006-12-20T21:12:44Z
nbknnt was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(3)
Rated as Best Answer

 

All Answers
Order by

 
13 helpful answers

Generally, spanking is out of favour nowadays. Still, most of humanity used it until very recently, and not many children were severely damaged by it. Some were, however, and some still are, as we can read in the newspapers from time to time.

"A little spanking," as your question put it, is not very precise. Some people would take that to mean spanking only when used to avert something terrible, like a child preparing to set the house on fire. Others would think that any beating that does not result in injuries requiring medical attention is perfectly all right. Need I say that the second group are wrong?

As far as the use of physical violence is concerned--and let's face the fact that a spanking is violent by its very nature--parents are best advised to avoid it. You aren't allowed to spank your spouse or your employees, so why should you be free to assault your child? 

Posted 2006-12-15T20:44:57Z
nbknnt was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
72 helpful answers

I am sorry if you misunderstood me what I meant was using small amount of force to teach the child discipline..

Posted 2006-12-20T17:40:10Z
 
13 helpful answers

Each child responds in different ways to different forms of discipline.  Some children require spanking; and when I say spanking, I don't mean hurting them, as it should never be so hard as to cause harm.  However, when you spank and then later tell them not to hit when they hit, it is very confusing to a child.  I have found that with my children, just the threat of spanking is enough to keep them from misbehaving.  This is not my only form of discipline, I also take away things that are important to them such as games or tv time.  Some children respond to this technique, some to timeouts, some to re-directing; it really depends on the individual child and each parent needs to figure what works for their child.

Posted 2006-12-25T20:42:21Z
 
72 helpful answers

Thank you all

Posted 2007-01-04T15:53:14Z
 

There are stages on a child's life that spanking is effective, as the child grows there are different approaches and rewarding it with

baby gifts when they do good is effective also.
Posted 2007-07-18T22:50:31Z
 
72 helpful answers

your link was broken...

Posted 2007-07-28T12:09:21Z
 

I need answers!

from my personal experience, spanking isn't a good form of punishment or whatever reasoning a parent use for spanking their child. i was spanked as a child and hated it, when my little sister and I were younger we were afraid of our dad, who was the only one who spanked us. granted, my dad has anger issues and is probably bi-polar, but i was still afraid of him as a child. flicking your child isn't good, again from my personal experience.

Posted 2008-12-04T02:07:01Z
 

If you watch how the kids who have never been beaten up by the parnets turn up, you will consider it...When I was a kid I was also beaten up for doing wrong and I thank my parents for it. It thought me a good lesson and I became a responisble and good adult.Back than I was mad at them but as the years passed by I realized it was the best method.

These spankless modern methods just allow our kids to be influenced by the tv, esspecialy mtv. And I don't want that my kid behaves like the people on the mtvs ''reality shows''.

If the parents don't lead the kids on the right way who will? The teachers? Kids these days have no respect for the teachers, because they have to much rights.

Back then we were affraid of the teachers and we had respect, not only for the teachers but for all pepople.

So what I'm trying to say is, spanking the kids or better beating them up is not going to damage them but lead them on the right path. Of course the kid has to know why is he beaten up.

 

 

Posted 2009-02-13T07:22:47Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for gabriwa? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

How do I deal with an Angry Child ?

How do I deal with an Angry Child ?
Submitted by Empowering Parents   9 months ago.
  • viewed 265 times
Last answer posted 3 months ago by Nanadee


Q:

What is jodi child-link "the link" and what ...

what is jodi child-link "the link" and what services do they offer? Thank you@!
Submitted by itsme   7 months ago.
  • viewed 72 times


Q:

What is the best way to protect your children from abduction or worse, child molestation predators?

What is the best child abduction protection & information program? Having seen in the news more and more child abductions, and ...
Submitted by EZStopSmoking   1 year ago.
  • viewed 321 times
Last answer posted 2 months ago by Robert



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Physical Discipline: To Spank or Not

children. Most people, including some child development experts, seem to believe that limited to speak against the harsh discipline of earlier times and suggested that children were individuals effective tools for influencing behavioral change. Why throw out an effective tool? As long as discipline

Gentle discipline + logical consequences?

But can anyone tell me if gentle discipline is more or less compatible with logical-consequences style discipline? I'd like to keep things as simple as possible for our daughter... also does anyone know . But anyway, all this was in response to the OPs questions about "logical consequence-style discipline

#8: Discipline

Workshop #8 - Discipline. Welcome to our eighth discussion: Discipline; This discussion will key in on Part 5 – Family Matters from Peggy O’Mara’s book . Some of the topics we'll discuss are; Chapter I am really excited about this. I definitely do my best to use gentle discipline now. Like everyone
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License