• Answers
  • Web

Sweetbread--Religious and Historic Significance and Connotation in Robert Frost's Poem

Is there a religious or historic reason some people like to eat sweetbread? Sweetbread can be defined as "the thymus of a young animal (as a calf) used for food," but has additional definitions. Also, can someone interpret how sweetbread is connoted in Robert Frost's poem Quandary


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

Posted Answers

 
32 helpful answers

Hi, Ted,

I cannot attest to any religious or historic reason why people eat sweetbread -- only that of those who've tried it, most say it is extremely delicious when prepared correctly. 

Yes, sweetbread is derived from the thymus of a young animal such as a calf.  We, too, have a thymus (or two of them, as young animals do), one in the neck/throat area and one centered near the heart, which disappear as we age just as the animals' do, which is why sweetbreads come from young animals. 

As Frost explains in "Quandary," he, too, thought that "sweetbreads" meant "brains," but was corrected by a butcher, a cook and a scientific book.  The confusion may have begun because of the similarity between the words "thymus" and "thalamus," the former being a gland, the latter, a part of the brain.

From the Farmer's Cookbook at http://www.bartleby.com/87/0015.html comes the following description:

"A SWEETBREAD is the thymus gland of lamb or calf, but in cookery, veal sweetbreads only are considered. It is prenatally developed, of unknown function, and as soon as calf is taken from liquid food it gradually disappears. Pancreas, stomach sweetbread, is sold in some sections of the country, but in our markets  this custom is not practised. Sweetbreads are a reputed table delicacy, and a valuable addition to the menu of the convalescent."

In human infants and children, the thymus gland(s) are essential to the development of our immune systems, and the same is probably true for animals.  Perhaps Frost was referring to a state of good health that he attributed to eating sweetbreads, particularly in light of the last phrase of the above description.   Or, he was using a bit of satire as poets are oft known to do.

 

Posted 2008-08-19T02:09:32Z
KnowTheTruth was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Ted E.? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Religion vs spirituality..years ago i had a paper ...

religion vs spirituality..years ago i had a paper that had a list of differences between spirituality and religion. it began with ...
Submitted by kato7547   12 days ago.
  • viewed 74 times
Last answer posted 3 days ago by El


Q:

Religion and Science: Compatible?

Do you engage in religious cognition and thus attribute unobservable causal mechanisms to cause and effect relationships? What ...
Submitted by Physicalist   5 days ago.
  • viewed 71 times
Last answer posted 4 hours ago by Helio Ramos


Q:

What do you think/know of the Free Mason's?

What do you think/know of the Free Mason's?
Submitted by Hanz   1 year ago.
  • viewed 716 times
Last answer posted 25 days ago by wolf1x1



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Futility of the evolution vs. creation and science vs. religion debate

That the science vs. religion and creation vs. evolution debate is futile and irrelevant, simply... they are mutually inclusive. Science does not disprove religion and evolution is not mutually exclusive think religion offers toward understanding ourselves that science dosen't?Do you read much poetry...

Myth vs Science - How to Inspire the White Man

Of natural science. This fact alone suggests that we need more readily accessible vehicles (art, films vs GuessedWorker re O'Meara's winning essay for TOO.] Myth Revisited Aug 18th, 2009 by Prozium , the myth vs science is perilously close to the mechanistic fallacy: the idea that Whites and WN

twdcjgads vs stantheman

BY AN ABSENCE OF ECONOMIC INCENTIVES. W.C. Lattin – Environmental Science Program, University of Idaho studies on the technology and policy of renewable energy. Former science teacher for four years same rules 100 word leeway on speechs, we need judges.
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License