• Answers
  • Web
Answer 182 out of 260
 
A:

DYK  (and Physicalist)

You gave many answers so expect a long response…..

Gabriel did not give Muhammad the Quran, tradition asserts that Muhammad was given what to say and scribes wrote it down. Historically if any of Muhammad's claim is true none of the quotes conclusively exists today. Years of wars and multiple “clergy” factions translating any leftovers of a possible bits and pieces of the original recitations were destroyed and finally something resembling an orderly documentation of what is considered a Quran today is mostly fiction, incorrect chronology, misuse of actual names, constructs of other religious beliefs, and not worthy of any credible reason to be taught as the words of Muhammad let alone the words of God through the angel Gabriel.   The earliest origins of anything that could be considered the Quran was complied almost 200 years after the death of Muhammad, by then much of any original recitations were lost and for lack of a structural grammar base for a logical understanding of what was written was up for grabs to be given any meaning commentaries wanted to give it.  With all this said I would compare the Quran with the book of Mormons, and the Jehovah Witness’ translation rewriting of the bible to fit their doctrine. The present day Quran is not a credible book for Muslims to base their faith upon as the words of Muhammad. No original manuscripts exist to prove the accuracy of the translations or the commentaries.

The Bible on the other hand does have original manuscripts available to compare translations with to get a more accurate understanding for the meaning of scripture. The fact that the Bible is God’s Word is stated in the scriptures, 2 Timothy 3:16

All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:

 

Having read the account in Numbers 31 of Robert Ingersoll’s statement, he exaggerated the Biblical account to mean something it does not. God had a quarrel with the Midianites for what they did to the Israelites, thus telling Moses to assemble an army to destroy that nation.  The military did not fulfill God’s command to its fullest by not destroying everything; the lives that were spared where to be executed, except the virgin female women and female children. They were not divided among the men for sexual gratification, but rather as was the custom, for slavery. Robert is obviously ignorant about this.

 

The Bible is boring to a sinner but not for a Christian. Without the Holy Spirit the Bible is just another book among the thousands; black ink on white paper. Before I gave my heart to Christ this is how the Bible was for me, as it is for you.  After having given my heart to Christ and being filled with the Holy Spirit, the Word of God became a living person. There is clarity and a depth beyond the three dimensional that transcends human logic and thought to a God who is more real than life itself and cannot be dismissed with the likes of an atheist. As I have told you “I don’t believe God exists, I know He does.” It is a lie to conceive that God is an extraterrestrial being way out in space waiting for the time of his choosing to return in a space ship to whisk us away to some far distant planet (that is a fairy tale Physicalist would be more apt to believe, science being his pet fetish).

 

You are incorrect, Lucifer and the angels are not human, we are not their descendants. Eve was deceived Adam was not and it is for this reason that the sin nature is passed on through the male and not the female. With this fact that is why Jesus had to be born of a virgin, for if He had a human father Jesus could not have been the Son of God and sinless. You are the one that does not understand God’s word always trying to circumvent it.

 

I see you believe the “swoon theory” of Jesus’ death, burial, and resurrection. Let us see what would happen to you if you went through what He did for mans redemption, then be stabbed in the heart and live for three days in a tomb with your face tightly wrapped in cloth; then come out alive to eat with the disciples (how ignorant you behave when you get frustrated). The people who saw Jesus ascend into heaven had no doubt who He is; not only His appearance but also the wounds proved Him to be Jesus.

The reality of what God wants concerning homosexuals is repentance from the sin of homosexuality. God gave the inhabitants of Sodom and Gomorrah plenty of opportunity to repent of their abominations, through the preaching of Lot, but they refused to do so. Yes, Lot was foolish to offer his daughters obviously his concern for the angels overcame is common sense. The inhabitants sealed their fate when they were willing to kill Lot to get to the angels, God had mercy long enough; God sent judgment. You do greatly err not knowing the God you ignorantly accuse as if He were a human instead of a Holy Spirit. God will not let sin and rebellions go unpunished, He will eventually send judgment.

 

Concerning blasphemy and the Holy Spirit:

 

DYK wrote: “A single Christian, stating this kind of thing in the public domain, would most likely get arrested.”

 

True. It happened to Jesus first and continues to happen today, especially where being a Christian is outlawed. Concerning ignorance, Jesus said on the cross, Father forgive them for they know not (ignorance) what they do.”

 

DYK where are all the famous people you quote, are they all dead or almost ready to die; all fools for rejecting Christ and you chose to follow in their footsteps. Give your heart to Christ and stop fighting a losing battle against God. Ask Satan, he knows he will not win, yet he wants you to believe you can, how terribly deceived you and Physicalist are what a tragedy.

 

I did tell you:

 

I don’t need you to reiterate your position about what I have written I know these statements mean nothing to you, but someday they will…

 

Samuel   11/7/2009    11:31 pm EDT

Helpful?(1)
Rated #54 out of 260

5 Comments About This Answer Add a comment

 
DYK

Samuside wrote:  The people who saw Jesus ascend into heaven had no doubt who He is; not only His appearance but also the wounds proved Him to be Jesus.

 

DidYouKnow writes:  Can you name one, just one, independent soul who witnessed anything concerning Jesus, who was not of the fold?  Name one.  Suggest one.  Construe one.

If you come up with no one, then ask yourself why Jesus didn't appear to non believers.  Ask why this would not have been the natural choice in order to complete a mission of convincing the world he was who he claimed, and who his believers thought he was.  Think.  Why not appear in front of Pilate?  In front of independent others who could report and record?  Why not?

 
DYK

Samuside wrote:   DYK where are all the famous people you quote, are they all dead or almost ready to die; all fools for rejecting Christ and you chose to follow in their footsteps.

 

DidYouKnow writes:  I'm not sure where you're going with the above.  Perhaps you might write it again?

 

Samuside wrote:   Give your heart to Christ and stop fighting a losing battle against God.

 

DidYouKnow writes:  Give your heart to Allah....right now, your three in one, one is three belief has you bound for a fiery non ending torment....Give your heart to Allah.  Respect Jesus as a prophet, an important prophet, but give your heart to Allah.  Peace be upon you.

 

Samuside wrote:  Ask Satan, he knows he will not win, yet he wants you to believe you can, how terribly deceived you and Physicalist are what a tragedy.

 

DidYouknow writes:  The only tragedy is the dead minds of the superstitious.  This deadness truncates humanness.

 
DYK

NUMBERS 31:17-18 – God commanded Moses to kill all of the male Midianite children and “kill every woman who has slept with a man, but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man.” The virgins are presumably raped. (NOTE: How could the soldiers know which women were virgins?)

 
Physicalist

Dear Samuside--DYK continues to have it right! I may add that it seems that Jesus was invented by committee! There is no Nazareth. 

We are risen apes, not fallen angels. You seem to have a super attachment to the supernatural because you fear death. Are you believing superstitious fictions of the ancient world because you rather be safe than sorry? All your Biblical beliefs are counter-intuitive in cosmology, biology, physics and psychology. You have such poor evidence; Only 36% of the Earth believe like you do after 2000 years. Christian numbers are dwindling in civilized and educated societies.

Your claims to know god or to be in communication with him is silliness, nonsense, and arrogance. You are clearly suffering from mass delusions. Marx said religion is the opiate of the masses. How did you get addicted? Usually it comes from the early childhood inculcation of dogma-based propaganda (as opposed to evidence or confirmed historical data). What is the nature of your very intense and deep affliction? 

Sincerely,

Physicalist

 

 
DYK

Samuside wrote:  "Having read the account in Numbers 31 of Robert Ingersoll’s statement, he exaggerated the Biblical account to mean something it does not.

 

DidYouKnow writes:  No, Mr. Ingersoll read it correctly.  The virgins were given to the soldiers.  Those soldiers did not adopt those very young women as daughters.  Your apologist's attempts always will weaken and cheapen your own religious beliefs concerning the benign and loving, merciful and just God.  Mr. Ingersoll read it correctly.

Samuside wrote:    God had a quarrel with the Midianites for what they did to the Israelites, thus telling Moses to assemble an army to destroy that nation. 

 

DidYouKnow writes:  Why is it that this God of yours comes across as so impotent?  He's always at the mercy of his created man creatures, be they His chosen or not, reacting, instead of acting in order to head His troubles off at the pass.  Just think, an almighty, all-knowing God who can't take solve problems from those He created, and is forced to KILL them all.  You say that God "had a quarrel" with the Midianites, ALL of them, to include the babies?  To include the pregnant women?  To include the elderly?  To include the mentally ill?  To include the bedridden, the crippled, the toddlers, the teenagers?  Your God was so incapable of communication and educating that the only resort he had was to KILL?  But not quite everybody; He made sure to leave the little girls for the use of the soldiers, and syphoned off some 10% of them for the clergy's use.

 

Samuside wrote:  The military did not fulfill God’s command to its fullest by not destroying everything;

 

DidYouKnow writes:  And you can write this, Samuside, with a clear conscience and what you think is a good heart.  Even if your God had wanted the executed to be skinned alive and dismembered, instead of just having their throats slit, or their heads bashed in by rocks, or their bodies cut to shreds by the thrusts of swords, you would not bat an eyelash, describing the horror of God's commands.  Why is that, Samuside?  Why is that?

 

Samuside wrote:   ..the lives that were spared where to be executed, except the virgin female women and female children.

 

DidYouKnow writes:  A war crime under the laws of mankind.  Why is that, Samuside?  Why does mankind have a Geneva Convention?  Why have rulers and dictators been imprisoned and put to death for ordering and doing the very same things that your God ordered and did?  If God uses the method of genocide, is it not, still, genocide?  God, who is the Creator, who is described as benign, loving, merciful, just and kind, of all entities should be able to avoid the carnage, of all entities should be able to correct and educate....and LOVE all of his creations.  He, at the very least, should be able to intervene, intelligently, appropriately, and represent all that is good.  But no, your God is a Monster.  And as I've asked on several occasions, does it take monsters to worship a Monster?

 

Samuside wrote:  They were not divided among the men for sexual gratification, but rather as was the custom, for slavery. Robert is obviously ignorant about this.

 

DidYouknow writes:  The ignorance is the disease of your kind of mind, Samuside, who reads the obviously tall stories and pretends they are true.  And with your willfully ignorant reading, you gloss over what is obvious, that your God is not a real God, but a petty, voracious bloodthirsty Monster, worshipped by petty people who represent what is woefully wrong with minds who are drowned with superstition.

Just look at your cavalier gloss over of slavery, merely referring to it as "the custom of the day," but not saying it was God's custom, God's idea.  Slavery was condoned, sanctioned, the rules set up, by your God....another CRIME.

 
Comment About This Answer (or add your own answer)

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners