• Answers
  • Web

Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum on New York gay pride parade

Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum took part in the New York gay pride parade and said that "Those who use religion to advocate an anti-gay agenda I believe are blaspheming God's name.". This is probably not what most religious Jews  think, and that fact that Rabbi Kleinbaum is a woman hints that she's not your average rabbi :)

So I'd like to know how many of the Jewish community actually support Rabbi Kleinbaum's views. Is it 5%? 10%? more? less?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

4 Posted Answers
Order by

 
1 helpful answer

The vast majority of orthodox Jews would be totally opposed to gay behaviour. Homosexual behavious is explicitly forbidden in the Bible for men and the ancient Rabbis forbade it also for women. No G-d-fearing Jew can support it. A gay pride parade is shamelessly publicising a sin on the streets. Others for whom the Bible and the halachic literature are not their beacon, may think otherwise

Posted 2007-06-27T16:02:24Z
Michaeli was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
18 helpful answers

I believe she would have to do some very creative work at interpreting the Bible in order to justify her stance religiously.  Jewish law is not a Chinese menu.  We can't just take the parts we like and use them.  Certainly most traditional Jews would have difficulty with her statement.

Posted 2007-07-24T20:28:04Z
 
10 helpful answers

In the United States, the Reform, Reconstructionist, and Conservative movements have all taken official positions in favor of gay rights. Those three movements represent about 80% of affiliated Jews. Of the unaffiliated Jews I think they would overwhelmingly support gay rights as well.

Those three movements all welcome women into their seminaries, so the idea of a rabbi being a man with a long beard is quickly becoming a stereotype of the past. 

Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum is correct, in my opinion, according to my conscience. There is nothing immoral in people forming committed relationships with the person they love, they desire.

A "religious" approach that claims authoritative understanding of a sacred text, claiming that God is the author of that interpretation, is a perversion of religion because it gives individuals an excuse to turn off their conscience.

The story of the Garden of Eden in Genesis comes to teach us that our consciences have been turned on. We were given the ability to distinguish between good and evil. To take that God-given ability and discard it at the directive of some "authority" is, in my opinion, an abomination.

I've written about the abuse of sacred text on my blog and how it serves the human spirit when personal responsibility is affirmed and "authoritative" readings of texts are rejected.

For an elaborate, fun, and deep contemporary interpretation of the Garden of Eden story, read Philip Pullman's "His Dark Materials" trilogy. 

Posted 2007-11-27T18:14:57Z
Helpful?(12)
Rated as Best Answer
 

Jewish tradition is pro-love, pro-healthy sexuality, pro-partnership, pro-people selecting their own partners (see midrash in which Adam rejects each of the animals in turn before selecting Eve as his partner), and anti-aloneness.

I support Rabbi Kleinbaum's views, and look forward to the day when no one will think the biggest problem in this country or in the Jewish community is that two people love each other and want to create a sacred family. 

Posted 2007-12-10T15:08:45Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Mark06? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Best Pride Parade in the World

Which city in the world holds the best Pride Parade?
Submitted by Albert   3 years ago.
  • viewed 1048 times
Last answer posted 5 months ago by Rx78


Q:

Mermaid Parade

I am mailing this from the Coney Island Mermaid Parade, I love this celebration (it’s my second time) and I wonder what other ...
Submitted by doglove   2 years ago.
  • viewed 717 times
Last answer posted 2 years ago by WenKroy


Q:

Gay parade in rome

There's a hell of a mess around the gay parade in Jerusalem, which is planned for this Friday. Most of the religious people in ...
Submitted by left_speaker   3 years ago.
  • viewed 1153 times
Last answer posted 3 years ago by carloz



» More...

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License