I have been a professional pilot for 35 years. I have flown all types of piston and jet aircraft. The training along the way was not always in simulators, although it had it's place. I flew with seasoned line Captains. Men who cam up through the ranks, and I did too. When I made Captain I too was seasoned.
In todays airline world there is too little time in the right seat(Co-pilot)before upgrade. Flying is not all about pushing buttons. There is some dgree of computerazition; yet there is an old aviation saying" There is no subtitute for experience" This is what makes the correct decision at critical times; like Buffalo...
I would love to share other opinions. I can be contacted @ joe55atp@aol.com