• Answers
  • Web

Dum Vivo Spero

Persecuting Catholics

I was recently given a booklet titled "Trail of Blood" by a Baptist friend.  My husband read through it and apparently, it is extremely anti-Catholic.  My question is this...as it stands ALL religions throughout the world have had their run-in with darkness...so...why is it that people single-out the Catholic religion as a cult or non-Christian religion?  Considering Peter founded the faith, our faith, the first Christian faith, I'm a little confused.


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

29 Posted Answers
Order by

 
16 helpful answers

It is never too late.  God loves you and wants a relationship with you no matter what you have done in your life.  He stands at the door and knocks.  Let him in. 

Hello Mondabi, 

I am not sure if Catholic was in fact the first Christian religion.  John the Baptist?  He was going around baptizing people but I don't think he was "Catholic."  I think the reason some are saying that it is a cult is that the Catholic priests tried to keep the rites and rituals to themselves (all in Latin) so that they would have all the power and all the money.  They teach that you can pray for someone who is already dead and your prayers can get him into heaven.  If you don't accept Jesus Christ as your savior before you die you don't get another chance.  They teach that you need to pray to saints or confess to a priest.  God wants us to come directly to him with our needs, concerns, wishes, and anything we desire.  He will answer our prayers.  They teach that works will get you to heaven.  Accepting Jesus Christ is the only thing required to enter heaven.  Good works flow from having been saved and not the other way around.  They teach that you must give a percentage of your income.  Giving flows from a joyful heart that is greatful for the gift of grace and wanting to further the kingdom of God.  There are other things such as the extra books they believe should be in the Bible.  What Martin Luther (Lutherens) and Tyndale (printed the English Bible)did was revealed to the world that you didn't need to pay the Catholic church to get into heaven and the common man could read the Bible and understand it and they did not need the Catholic church to act as an intercessor to God.  The first Christians were disciples of Jesus.  The Catholic church tried, and was very successful for a long time, to hi-jack the simple truths of Jesus for their own profit, power, and benefit.   If you have any more questions I would be glad to respond.  I am not a fanatic that thinks it is a cult.  I think that there are certian things that are necessary to believe if you are a Christian. In those things we need unity.  In nonessentials we need grace and in all other things we need love.    Sincerely, dave

 
29 helpful answers

I am not familiar with the booklet to which you refer. I can respond to the remainder of your question, however. The reason that protestants and Baptists have problems with some Catholic beliefs is that all of these denominations believe that Jesus alone provides salvation and entrants into the presence of God. These denominations further believe that Jesus is our intercessor (John 14:6). For intercession we don't need a pastor, a priest, a deacon or the Pope. Praying to some saint defined and named by the church is not supported by scripture. Furthermore, praying to the mother of Jesus is not supported by scripture. The saints and His mother can do nothing for you. We can pray directly to the Father who gives forgiveness for sin directly. He also would direct us in any action we should be involved with regarding any sin of which we are asking forgiveness. Peter was not the founder of the faith, our faith, nor was he the first Christian faith. The only scripture of which I am aware that the Catholic religion uses to base their belief is Mathew 16:18-19. This is the 'keys to the kingdom' scripture. The most natural understanding of this passage is to see some special importance attached to Peter. The New Testament certainly attached some primacy to Peter. Peter is always listed first in any list of apostles. He was always in the innermost circle around Jesus. He preached the sermon at Pentecost. Many other times Peter seemed to be the one out front. On the other hand, there is no indication that Peter had any particular authority over the apostles. He did not send apostles; they sent him(Acts 8:14). James was the leader of the mother church in Jerusalem (Acts 21:18), not Peter. Paul could openly rebuke Peter at Antioch(Galations 2:11). There is no evidence that Peter was ever made bishop or pope over the whole church or that any special office was transmitted from him to another. It is unfortunate that the scripture that the Catholich church uses to justify the office of Pope and Peter as the first pope has been made a point of controvery. It is clearly 'proof-texting'. Jesus was the rock on which the church is built, not Peter. Peter is neither the head, not the founder of the church; Jesus is. The church rises or falls on Him. The church which Jesus promised to build is His church. I have many catholic friends. I have witnessed to many catholic people whom I did not know. In every case, they would not accept the basis of their salvation to be 'Jesus alone'. In every case their salvation was based upon what the Pope had to say. This is clearly in opposition to what Jesus said as reported in the Bible. I hold not feelings of animosity toward catholic people. I love them all. Their belief regarding Peter as the first pope and the Pope, in general, is misplaced and in the end will cause them great difficulty.

Posted 2009-01-15T18:14:52Z
DeaconKW was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
36 helpful answers

Dum Vivo Spero

I appreciate your answer and taking the time to pull out scripture at that.  I do, however, disagree.  In my experience, Catholics who think their salvation "road map" is laid out by the Pope are Catholics who do not properly adhere to their own faith.  As Catholics, we believe that Jesus Christ is our Lord and Saviour, absolutely.  We believe that only He has been able to save us, absolutely.  However, we also believe that it is not by faith alone that we are saved.  I am not a scholar, so I won't pretend that I can go toe-to-toe with someone regarding specific scriptures.  I can tell you that as a practicing Catholic (attend Mass EVERY Sunday, on all Holy Days, follow the Ten Commandments as best I am able, adhere to Church teachings regarding Christ -- founded in scripture, yes), scriptures are often taken out-of-context.  It is not simply by one or two verses alone that you understand what was intended.

You must understand the author of that chapter of the Bible.  You must also look to his audience at the time and read the entire book.  You, yourself, can surely agree that the Bible, when taken literally, contradicts itself many times.  Therefore, we must all be careful on how we interpret it.  It was Peter who carried on in Jesus' name and continued what is now known as the Catholic faith.  It was also the Catholic Church that put together the Bible...the very thing that you quote to others.  Understand that nothing done in the Catholic faith contradicts the Bible.  How would that make sense, afterall, since it was the Catholic Church who put together all the scripture everyone who is a Christian now reads.

We can always get into the discussion about Protestants and Luther.  However, you must realize that it is NOT only the Catholic Church that suffered from within.  You cannot find a religion that did not succumb at some point in its history to the temptation and begin to corrupt its very being.

Catholicism is completely and totally about God and Jesus Christ.  We pray for the Saints and Mary to pray FOR us.  We do not pray to them as God or sub-gods.  It's no different than when you ask your congregation or a friend to pray for you and your needs.  When you attend a Catholic Mass, everything from the music, to the adoration of Christ in the Eucharist, to the scriptures read is honestly about God and Christ.  It is not about the preacher or any one individual.  It's about our Father in Heaven and you are fully aware of that the entire service.  I find it so beautiful and feel the true presence of Christ while there.  It's prayerful and reverant. 

Reconciliation is something that Christ called us to do, as well.  It was He who gave the Apostles the ability to forgive or retain sins, as well.  When we reconcile, we are holding ourselves accountable to God, not to the priest who hears our confession.  There's no easy way out when you know you have to express that sin out loud.  It is God who forgives us our sins.  And, there are several scriptures that refer to us being called to reconcile ourselves with our sins.

Regardless, it's great you are passionate, albeit one-sided.  I converted to Catholicism after a lifetime of being anti-Catholic, myself.  Over time, the more I sat down to learn the truth about it - not simply the one-sided and often, misguided teachings of Protestants - the more I began to see it as pure and beautiful way to follow Christ in my life.  Not just as an evangelical or being "just good enough."  But, by answering the call Christ put onto my heart to truly live with Him at the center of my life.  That means to love all, to pray for all, to strive to bring Christ to all.

May peace be with you.

Chris

PS - Regarding the "extra books in the Bible" - this is another misconception.  The truth is that Luther TOOK OUT books from the Bible that disagreed with what he thought should be there.  Those books had been in the Bible for hundreds of years prior to that.  There was corruption, yes, and Luther was right to point it out.  Unfortunately, what ended up happening was that corruption reared its ugly head once again in his new religion/faith, as well.  Proving that it is not the Bible nor the religion that was faulty, but rather, it is Man.  No one is above temptation and failure.  For each of us, we have a different pull.  However, to change what God has left here on Earth for us to follow is not something that should ever be done.

Ultimately, those who misled others from God's true way will pay a heavy price.  We can argue amongst ourselves for years to come.  Only when Christ comes for us will we know the truth.  In the meantime, I will continue along my path of doing all that I can by way of Faith and Works...as I believe Jesus intended.

Posted 2009-01-20T16:09:57Z
 
16 helpful answers

I have come into this world to experience this: men so true to love they would rather die before speaking an unkind word..to see this:the sword drop from men's hands even at the height of their arc of rage because we have finally realized there is just one flesh we can wound. ~Hafiz~

 

If I were the devil fighting a spiritual battle would I try to stop the man with an automatic or the man throwing sticks and stones... The Truth is that where there is the most Truth to inform us on how to live an overcoming life in this world which means a life that overcomes evil, that Church of Truth is going to receive a great deal more persecution than those Churches which have less truth and which are less deadly to satan. I will give you an example. Mary whom God (Father, Son and Holy Ghost) chose above all women in all generations to be the Mother of Jesus (the Son of God) said "All generations will call me blessed".  Catholics do this everytime they pray the Rosary asking her to pray for us. Now we know Mary entered eternal life and is in heaven because if she who was chosen above all women in all generations did not gain this, then who of us has a chance? And if she is in heaven where sin does not exist, then we know she can do no sin from there. If we can ask angels to pray for us, and she is higher than an angel, then we know we can ask the mother of Jesus to pray for us. If Mary petitions Jesus for something on our behalf and Jesus taught us to obey our parents, do you not think that Jesus Himself lives by his own rule? Thus she is one of the most powerful advocates we have to pray with us when we are in need. That makes her a mighty powerful weapon against evil and satan. So why then have nearly all other denominations of Christianity fail to recognize this? It is because satan has undermined their faith through promulgating the notion that we have the "right" to interpret Scripture for ourselves and do not have to rely on the method Jesus put in place to pass His teachings down to us through TEACHERS.

Eph 4: 4 There is one body, and one Spirit, ...5 One Lord, one faith, one baptism, 6 One God and Father of all, ...11 And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and TEACHERS; 12 For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: 13 Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ:

If there is only ONE faith then why is there a different denomination on every street corner? Because these other denominations were protesting against the teachings of the Church, and that is why they are called PROTESTANT. The origins of Protestant denominations can only be traced back to the schism in the 1500 and 1600's when they broke away from the Catholic Church and they have continued to divide and subdivide since that time. (A house divided against itself cannot stand). But as you read in the passage I included there was a Prophesy that said Jesus would return when the Church was reunited in their understanding of Christ or in other words, when the whole body of believers returned to the original teachings. Only that prophesy that foretold the reunification, also fortold of the schism because the Church at that time had not suffered from men breaking off from the Church to start their own religions in the name of Christ.  So our separated brethren often labeled Protestants have been handed down a diluted portion of the Truth and thus it has became less harmful to satan than the full strength portion that remains in the Catholic (Universal) Church. So  satan isn't going to bother with those throwing sticks and stones as those who tromp on his head like Mary the Mother of God and the heirs of the authentic Apostolic authority endowed them by God.This topic can be quite upsetting to me because many of the poor Protestants of today have never once been told the origins of their church and many think falsely that their denominations, complete with beliefs can be traced back all the way to Christ, when in fact some denominations like the Assembly of God, or Quakers are only a little over 100 years old and their teachings originated with some man who refused to be subject to what was being taught as was handed down from Christ. It's not fair to them to be taught such deceit and yet their pastors learned the history of their Church in seminary... but then their pastors need a paycheck so they keep the dirty little secret of the schism in the dark. Jesus said In the last days many will be deceived because many will come in my name teaching Christ.  I apologize for such a lengthy answer but we can only make informed decisions about our faith if we are fully informed about the Truth and this Truth can be verified with nearly any encyclopedia. I hope this helps.

Posted 2009-01-20T17:43:47Z
theresabbdavid was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
29 helpful answers

I read every word you have written and I appreciate your candor.  You sound very much like an evangelical Catholic  who believes in Jesus as the one providing salvation.  I never thought before of your example of praying to Mary in the same way that we ask our friends to pray for us.  I would not say that agree with you, but it is a consideration;  she is definitely not a diety.  I did not say anything about extra books of the Bible,  Macabbees being the only difference i am aware of.  Nor did I say anything about corruption, etc.  All in all,  based on this one encounter we don't sound like we're that far apart.

Posted 2009-01-20T17:49:17Z
DeaconKW was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
36 helpful answers

Dum Vivo Spero

Theresabbdavid........This was an excellent answer - thank you!  I truly appreciated the way you were able to put into words some more of the detail I referred to.  The Catholic faith is amazing and truly about our Lord.  I couldn't have converted had I not honestly believed that.  And, you're so right...Satan will not bother with those who are not a true threat to him.  Why would he, indeed?!  It will only become more difficult as time goes on, but my husband and I are ready.  We continue our prayers and follow our faith.  The Church learned directly from Christ and is our guide in all things holy while we're here on Earth.

Thank you for your comments and passionate response!

 
36 helpful answers

Dum Vivo Spero

DeaconKW......I am glad to hear that you are willing to at least consider our position regarding Mary and the Saints.  It is a common misconception, as are many things in our faith.  You will find that any encounter with a true Catholic will provide you with these types of answers.  As with any faith, there are always those who take the wrong approach or a "cafeteria style" to their faith.  Catholics are no exception to this.  That is the human flaw and bound to happen, unfortunately.  It typically occurs when people take it upon themselves to form their very personal opinion of what God wants.  Trouble with that is Satan has a lot of influence over us whether we choose to admit it or not (or, whether or not we're aware that he is trying to influence us at that time).  So, it's imperative that we not stray from the truth and Christ's true teachings...teachings that have been taught since the beginning and handed down through the generations...first as word-of-mouth, then by letters and finally, as a collection of all that we now call the Bible.

It's important that when asking questions or developing our opinions, we look for answers from those who are truly faithful and practicing in accordance with God.  He brought us our salvation and our Church.  It's our duty to adhere to ALL His teachings and bring Christ to others whether by evangelization, helping those in need, loving when love is most difficult or even by showing Christ in our own lives in the way WE live.

As for the other responses, I was actually responding to the comment made before yours.  Sorry that I clumped them together.

Thanks for your response!  God bless.

Chris

Posted 2009-01-20T20:48:43Z
 
36 helpful answers

Dum Vivo Spero

Dave - please see my response to another comment below.  I also address your comment about the "extra books."  thanks for your response!

Posted 2009-01-20T20:54:40Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Mondabi2000? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Children out of Wedlock !! Ur views Please...

What are CHRISTIANS and CATHOLICS views on children outside of Wedlock!?? And should we look down on GOD for having a SON outside ...
Submitted by paddster16   1 year ago.
  • viewed 1677 times
Last answer posted 25 days ago by Dorian37grey


Q:

The catholic church Because???

Catholic orders plead poverty in Irish abuse Reuters – A crow flies past the Papal Cross in Phoenix ...
Submitted by Moosemose   7 months ago.
  • viewed 276 times
Last answer posted 2 months ago by funguy


Q:

Marriage for Priests in the Catholic Church?

The Vatican has made it easier for Anglicans to keep their traditions, including married priests, when converting to Catholicism ...
Submitted by AOL News   2 months ago.
  • viewed 538 times
Last answer posted 1 month ago by canyoutakeajoke



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Catholicism is a denomination of Christianity, right?

Because people in my life are saying Catholicism and Christianity are 2 different religions . But isn't Catholicism a denomination of Christianity? and Christianity are 2 different religions. But isn't Catholicism a denomination of Christianity...

Religion Is Catholicism a form of Christianity?

To agree - Catholicism is a branch, part, subset, etc of Christianity. Also, if it means anything, I am In DevilWithAHalo's stickied post on Recognized Religions, it says: Quote: : Catholicism A belief of God and the redeemer of humanity. Catholicism most certainly is a form of Christianity, even

Catholicism VS Christianity DEBATE Justification

But it didn't work just search on youtube the thread title with a Catholic priest on John ankerberg are righteousn an God counts it as such.Quote: : If the debate is titled " Catholicism VS Christianity still Christians protesting error.Quote: : If the debate is titled " Catholicism VS Christianity
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License