Originated from
FANHOUSE

Why is Pat Tillman considered a hero ?

Why is Pat Tillman considered a "hero"?  Is it NFL "political correctness" or simply stupidity on the part of those who glorify Tillman: he was a lower-rung linebacker and a lousy soldier.  He should have stayed with the Cardinals and taken care of his family, instead of running off on a fool's errand to have his head blown off by his own squad members while he charged an enemy unit that didn't exist.  Now his brother, and parents, completely disclaim the so-called "war on terriorism", and completely discount the Tillman brothers fervent patriotism as melodramatic, self-aborbed hogwash. Heros are born, and not made. Unfortunately Pat Tillman confused the battlefield with the football field and paid the price. Canton, Ohio, and the NFL Hall of Fame should never be disparaged by such a debacle. Leave war to soldiers, and football to the players of games.


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

8 Posted Answers
Order by

 
1 helpful answer

every single soldier who has ever gone abroad and fought to protect our rights is a hero.  it is people like him who make it possible for us to take our rights for granted.

 

Richard, You are about as ignorant as they come. You are "Stupidity Magnified". If you left the USA, this would be a much better country. Your lack of common sense is a sad reflection of you. I pity people like yourself. There wouldn't be a USA if it wasn't for people like Pat Tillman. He died serving his country, there is a no more honorable way to die. He sacrificed for a cause he and many believed in. All you are is a negative, jealous critic who I am sure has not accomplished much with your small life. It is people like Pat Tillman who make this the greatest country on earth. Get a clue, a heart, some brains, some history, some reality and a Life. 

 

well richtard..you have never been in the service..i know this by the way you talk..pat was an exelent football player and i am sure an outstanding soldier..he was the most un selfish hero i have ever heard of.he left millions of dollars to go fight for me and everyone else in this country..yes he even fought for you to richtard..you would have taken the money and spent it like the fool you are..and said to hell with the country..thats as sad as the pathetic life you live..you wanted your 5 minutes of shame so here it is..get a grip dude and thank our soldiers and the man up stairs for every breath you take..without them you are nothing..or go with option number two..go tell a soldier to their face that they are lousy..we know you wont because they will stomp a mud hole in your ass.. so there is your 5 minutes of shame richtard

 

As to his football ability, Pat Tillman was, at the very least, a very good football player at the highest level of the sport.  Think of all who play high school football and how few make it to the NFL.  Your larger point is even more absurd.  This was a wealthy young man--by your standards--who went to serve his country voluntarily in a cause he believed.  From the comfort of your keyboard, you can second guess the mission and/or the cause, but you have that luxury because throughout the history of this country soldiers like Pat Tillman have protected you. 

 

Because he gave up millions of $$$ to serve his country thats why!!!

 

He was a hero by joining the army because he thought his country needed him and he was ready to do what he could to help keep us safe.   unfortunately we all know the sad story of what happened,  but he is a HERO.

 
1 helpful answer

Man, you are a joke. There is no polotical correctness or spin doctoring involved here, it is simply a good man doing a good deed and paying the ultimate price. Reffering to military service as "a fools errand" is disgusting, without men like Mr. Tillman you would be scrubbing bathrooms for some foriegn conquerer. Disagree with the war, thats fine, I do too. But disagree with a man for trying to save the asses of scum like you? And even giving up a lucrative proffesion to do so? Having a problem with that, is downright near criminal. Next time you question a true good deed, think a little harder first with whatever birdbrain you so obviously posses.

 
119 helpful answers

Work hard or go home.

Richard, give Tillman some credit. He did what you couldn't or at least didn't want to. He left a comfortable lifestyle to fight a war against those opposed to freedom. He wasn't poor; he didn't join to get a free education. He left because he felt it was his responsibility to protect his family and families like his. In that respect, he is a true hero in my book. Don't try to minimize what he did because you lack the ability to do it yourself.

Posted 2009-11-03T13:30:26Z
muscleguy was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Richard Smith? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Tillman? Hall of Fame? So he was a pro football ...

Tillman? Hall of Fame? So he was a pro football player. How about all the college and high school football players who were ...
Submitted by Hubert   1 year ago.
  • viewed 328 times
Last answer posted 3 months ago by Bags


Q:

STEELERS SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GO ...

STEELERS SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GO RAVENS!!!!!!!
Submitted by Huricanes football   1 year ago.
  • viewed 749 times
Last answer posted 11 months ago by George~


Q:

Why do you call Kemp an ***ex-NFL*** great?

Why do you call Kemp an ***ex-NFL*** great? He played ***one year*** (1957) in the NFL, with the Pittsburgh Steelers, where he was ...
Submitted by Remember the AFL   1 year ago.
  • viewed 499 times
Last answer posted 23 days ago by Adrian Stansfield


Be The First To Answser

Other people asked questions on various topics, and are still waiting for answer. Would be great if you can take a sec and answer them

» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Two NFL football teams coming to LA. NFL in LA for 2010 season.

A NFL team will be playing here in 2010. And he added that there is a 100 percent chance a team will play here in 2011. He also mentioned that there is a 50 50 chance two NFL teams will be here when there is a 50 50 chance a NFL team will be playing here in 2010. And he added that there is a 100 percent chance

NFL Football or soccer?

Which would be more enjoyable to view? NFL football is my favorite. Yours? NFL Football by far. Amongst other things the diving in soccer just ruins it for me.Probably Soccer , but football is pretty fun (soccer).Easily the NFL. Can't wait for the Bear's game tonight!Soccer.I

NCAA and NFL Football Season is almost here :: Thank God!!!

Go Broncos Should be some fun this year watching college and NFL football. Tell Me about it man, FOOTBALL!! YEAH!!Can the Lions have a winning season this year ? It's a retorical question - don't need an answer - O.K. !thank god is right. i love football. LSU Tigers fan
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT

The latest from FanHouse

Texas Tech Suspends Mike Leach

Filed under: Texas Tech , Big 12 , Coaching Texas Tech announced Monday afternoon that it has suspended head football coach Mike Leach after receiver Adam James and his father, ESPN analyst and former SMU running back Craig James, complained to the school about alleged mistreatment after the player sustained a serious head injury. Leach is currently being investigated by the school. Defensive coordinator Ruffin McNeill will assume the head coaching duties on an interim basis while the Red Raiders prepare to meet Michigan State in Saturday's Alamo Bowl. A source with knowledge of the situation confirmed that Leach is under investigation for allegedly sending a player into a darkened room after he came to practice wearing sunglasses as a result of a recent mild concussion. It has been confirmed that the unnamed player is sophomore receiver Adam James.

Del Negro Doesn't Think He'll Be Fired

Filed under: Bulls , NBA Rumors , NBA Coaches If Chicago's front office is planning on firing Vinny Del Negro, they haven't told him. That was the message Del Negro told reporters following Monday's practice, reacting to a report Sunday evening from ESPN's Chris Broussard that the decision to replace him has already been made, and that the team was simply looking for the right successor. Del Negro pointed to his daily communication with vice president John Paxson and GM Gar Forman as proof that his job was safe. "It's just funny to me," Del Negro said . "There's really nothing to say. You have all these people that have rumors, and everyone has their sources. It's just not accurate. I don't have time to deal with rumors. I talk to Gar and Pax every day. They're at practice every day." Later, Del Negro added "When you ask those questions, it's easy for me to say that, but go ask those guys. Go ask them. But I talk to them every day. ... Those are questions for them to answer. But it's really a waste of time, because I know we're on the same page." If Del Negro expected a public vote of confidence, it didn't happen; according to the Chicago Sun-Times , Chicago Tribune and ESPN Chicago, Paxson and Forman declined to comment on Del Negro's job security. They won't be able to ignore this rumor for long, though, so stay tuned.

Jets Could Get Another Gift Sunday -- and...

Filed under: Bengals , Colts , Jets , NFL Analysis FLORHAM PARK, N.J. -- While Indianapolis coach Jim Caldwell roasted Monday in the kind of heat only a sports-obsessed 24-hour news cycle can offer, the beneficiaries of the Colts ' decision gathered here to celebrate their good fortune. The New York Jets find themselves in that most blissful of late-December football positions -- control of their own destiny. If they beat the Bengals on Sunday night at home, they will be in the playoffs. And the real good news? The Bengals, already champions of the AFC North, don't need the game and could very well rest their stars against the Jets like the Colts did Sunday. "We're preparing as if Carson Palmer will be the quarterback and Chad Ochocinco will be a receiver and all that," Jets coach Rex Ryan said. "But Cincinnati's earned that right, and they'll make those choices."

Golden Boy CEO: 'Trying to Save'...

Filed under: WBA , WBC , IBF , WBO , Golden Boy Promotions , HBO , FanHouse Exclusive FanHouse caught up to Golden Boy Promotions' CEO, Richard Schaefer , whose company is handling the negotiations on behalf of Floyd Mayweather (40-0, 25 knockouts) for the potential blockbuster bout with seven-division world champion, Manny Pacquiao , who is the current WBO welterweight (147 pounds) titlist. Tentatively slated for March 13 at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas, Mayweather-Pacquaio was all-but done until a controversy surfaced over pre-fight drug-testing. Mayweather's camp is demanding that both fighters be tested using random urinalysis and bloodwork; Pacquiao is fine with the urine-testing, but would prefer not to have blood drawn within 30 days of the fight. Mayweather's side has softened its position of having the United States Anti-Doping Agency do the testing, just as Pacquaio's promoter, Top Rank's Bob Arum , seems to have eased up on the notion of random blood-testing, as long as it is done by the Nevada State Athletic Commission. Arum stated that Monday is the last day to get the deal done, or he will move on to signing up Pacquiao (50-3-2, 38 KOs) to face either New York's, junior middleweight (140 pounds) Paulie Malignaggi (27-3, five knockouts) or New York's WBA junior middleweight (154 pounds) champion Yuri Foreman (28-0, eight KOs) on March 13. "I can't imagine Manny Pacquiao walking away from $25 million because he refuses to have blood and urine drawn, and then going off to do something else and making half of that," said Mayweather's adviser, Leonard Ellerbe . "The clock is ticking, but I think that Manny Pacquiao will eventually step up and take the test." Schaefer sheds his views on the state of affairs in this Q&A below:

Florida Shouldn't Take Meyer Back

Filed under: Florida , SEC There isn't a doubt what those who run the University of Florida must do right now regarding Urban Meyer. They must tell him to go. They must do so after swallowing their pride while calling another news conference in New Orleans, where the Gators football team is preparing for the Sugar Bowl. This time, in contrast to the last time on Sunday, when Meyer said he changed his mind within 24 hours about resigning, they must tell their coach of five seasons that it has been a splendid ride along the way to two national champions that complemented a 56-10 record overall and a 32-8 mark in the SEC. Afterward, they must ignore the screaming that will come from the Gator Nation after they give Meyer a firm handshake on his way out of their coaching door forever. He's got to go, all right. He can't spend another moment e-mailing recruits during church services, as he said the other day. He can't move through more springs and summers battling the turmoil inside of his chest and his head. He definitely can't stand on the sidelines for another Florida game with Georgia, Tennessee or any of those other conference monsters across the way -- not if Meyer has spent the last few weeks, months and years suffering as much as he says he has been. As scenarios for burnout coaches go, this one doesn't pass the smell test. In fact, it just smells.

Mikael Samuelsson Is Not Happy With Olympic...

Olympic rosters are starting to be announced, and on Sunday team Sweden was presented to the public for the first time. It includes the obvious choices like Detroit's Henrik Zetterberg and Nicklas Lidstrom, Washington's Nicklas Backstrom and the Sedin twins, Henrik and Daniel. One name that's not on the roster is one of the Sedin's Vancouver teammates, Mikael Samuelsson . And he's not happy about it.

Who Gains Most From Tiger-less Tour?

Filed under: PGA , Golf Odds and Ends The PGA Tour next week begins a second consecutive season without its best player. Unlike last year, however, when Tiger Woods was rehabbing a surgically repaired knee in a hard-working push to return to competition, this season he has gone underground to hide from the backlash of a tawdry secret life. Last year, Woods' return to the PGA Tour was charted and awaited. Then year, when the SBS Championship -- a field of tournament winners -- tees off Jan. 7 in Kapalua, Hawaii, nobody has a clue what Woods' role will be in 2010.

Winter Classic: Weather Outside Is...

Filed under: Bruins , Flyers , Winter Classic One of these years, an NHL Winter Classic will be postponed. This is the reality of holding an open-air hockey game in the United States on January 1 when the weather is unpredictable. As wonderful as these events have been -- the light snow in Buffalo, the glory of Wrigley Field -- the week leading up to the Winter Classic will never fail to cause Gary Bettman, NHL marketing executives and everyone involved to toss and turn in their sleep. This week in Boston is no exception. Like most of the East, Massachusetts had unseasonably warm weather the last two days. On Monday, the rains came. NHL ice man Dan Craig said his weather forecasters initially told him to expect a 50 percent chance of snow on New Year's Day. Now their projections have changed to rain. Craig says he doesn't worry about what he cannot control. He has a job to do.

John Fox, Marty Hurney Invited Back to...

Filed under: Panthers , NFL Coaching , NFL Rumors Panthers coach John Fox and general manager Marty Hurney have been on the hot seat for nearly four years now. Last season's playoff run saved both their gigs for this season after a really disappointing year in 2007 that featured far too much Mittens (David Carr for the uninitiated). Then this season, Jake Delhomme couldn't shake the bug from last season's playoff loss to Arizona and it appeared that owner Jerry Richardson might just have to fire both of them, regardless of whether he wanted to or not. But late-season, semi-irrelevant blowout upset wins over the Vikings and Giants have apparently secured their future with the Panthers for at least one more year, according to the Charlotte Observer . Fox, whose contract will expire after the 2010 season, will not be offered an extension, however. Sources say he is scheduled to make about $6 million next season. Fox's entire coaching staff is also included in the invitation, which the Observer notes could also be related to the looming potential lockout.

Pam Ward Has Very Little Patience for...

Filed under: College Sports On Pam Ward's home planet there are no injuries. So it only make sense that she would have very little patience for the fragile existence humans lead on Earth. And knowing that explains this: while calling the Little Caesar's Pizza Bowl this weekend, Ward expressed frustration at the time it took to get an injured Marshall player off the field: "Get him off the field, please...Come on!" indeed. There are two ways to look at this. For the glass-half-full set: Ward is hoping the Marshall player is off the field so the game can resume when ESPN returns from break. Or two, Ward, like me, is an impatient jerk. I'm leaning toward the latter, but because it's the holiday season, I'll give Ward the benefit of the doubt. via Deadspin

Baron Davis Beats the Celtics at the Buzzer

Filed under: Celtics , Clippers , NBA Videos Exciting times Sunday night at Staples Center. The East-leading Celtics were in town to face the Clippers , which means it was one of the few nights when the arena was packed for L.A.'s second-class team. And the Clips did not disappoint. The teams were all tied up at 90 with exactly one second left on the clock. It was at that point that Baron Davis worked his magic, hitting an extremely tough, turn-around fadeaway jumper (at the 1:37 mark) to give his team the victory,

Steelers Calling on Hair, 'Stache Homages...

Filed under: NFL The Steelers defeated the Ravens Sunday to keep their slim playoff hopes alive for another week. And while the often maligned, Troy Polamalu -less secondary went another game without an interception, the front seven picked up the slack. James Farrior had a pick, LaMarr Woodley had two sacks and a forced fumble, rookie Ziggy Hood registered his first NFL sack and he recovered a fumble late in the fourth quarter that all but sealed the game. Backup defensive lineman Nick Eason managed just two tackles, but his performance was critical to the team's success. At least if you're of the opinion that at this point in the proceedings, luck has as much to do with winning as on-field excecution. And since the Steelers have lost eminently winnable games to the Chiefs, Raiders and Browns, that seems like a fair assessment. Which is why Eason should bust out the Steelers helmet Afro for the rest of the season, however long that lasts. Between that and Ben Roethlisberger 's "homage to Ken Anderson" (read: somebody got Anchorman for Christmas), the Steelers postseason hopes are suddenly somewhere north of "no way in hell."

Did Mangini, Morris Save Their Jobs?

Filed under: Browns , Buccaneers , NFL Coaching , NFL Analysis The hot item on Sunday's rumor mill was about Bill Cowher and the Bucs. Cowher, so the rumors went, had been approached by Tampa Bay about replacing Raheem Morris after it looked like Morris would go 2-14 in his rookie year. That was following the speculation all week about Mike Holmgren's intentions as the new president of the Browns toward Eric Mangini, who seemed to be coaching his way to oblivion. Except that the Bucs then went out and won their second straight game, 20-17 in overtime in New Orleans, over a team that until last week was unbeaten. And the Browns won their third straight, beating Oakland for their fourth victory of the season. At least Holmgren is a football man who will make the right choice for the right reasons. The Glazer family, owners of the Bucs, know so little about football that it took them six years to figure out that the Super Bowl they won after the 2002 season was the work of Tony Dungy and Rich McKay, not Jon Gruden and Bruce Allen, who they fired a year ago. Hey guys, if you're gonna clean house for a baby coach, at least give him some time to learn.

HausCast 42: Clay Travis Talks Urban Meyer

Filed under: College Sports , Sports Media , Podcast The FanHouse Podcast : Because bloggers are much sexier on the phone. FanHouse's Clay Travis joins HausCast to talk about the biggest sports news of the weekend: Urban Meyer 's decision to step down as the University of Florida's football coach. Unlike the Tiger Woods PR machine, which regularly tried to bury news, the Meyer story broke on a Saturday during a full slate of bowl games. The subject -- infidelity versus health issues -- obviously played a role, but why not wait until after the Sugar Bowl? Taking the longer view, what does this mean for the Gators' program, and more generally, the balance of power in the SEC? Clay also wonders if Lane Kiffin had something to do with Meyer's decision and whether Meyer will be able to stay off the sidelines in 2010. Talking starts after the jump.

Clemson Tops Kentucky in Music City Bowl,...

Filed under: Clemson , Kentucky , ACC , SEC , Bowl Games NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- With the wind swirling at up to 435 miles an hour -- potentially inflated due to my lack of meteorological training -- the Kentucky Wildcats and Clemson Tigers kicked off for the always exhilarating night game in late December. In Nashville. Between two Southern teams. The only thing less popular among these collective fan bases was the drive to legalize gay marriage via state constitutional referendum. As I walked across the Cumberland River buffeted by the strong air current, suddenly two small children were swept from their parents' grasp and floated, like tiny mewling dirigibles, slowly across the dark ribbon of the river to the east bank of Nashville. There the children, jaws still agape from their ride on the wind, sat in the shadows of the stadium awaiting the arrival of their stunned parents. OK, that didn't happen. But if it had it would have been indicative of the game to come: the wind was the MVP of the Music City Bowl. Ultimately, Clemson withstood the wind better than Kentucky did, pulling away for an uninspiring 21-13 victory and sending Kentucky's Rich Brooks into retirement. "I told my team, [there's] probably [an] 80 percent chance that I'm not coming back," Brooks said immediately after the loss. Let's break down how the game played out:
» More...
Powered by
ADVERTISEMENT
AOL Autos Q&A is powered by Yedda an AOL Company
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners