Subscribe: Subscribe to TipnutEmail or Subscribe to Tipnut.comRSS Tipnut Subscribers

Originated from
Web4health
Asked about “Get personal advice

Mother/daughter relationship

My parents got divorced long time ago. I rarely saw my father. I lived with my mom and grandma. When I was 11, my mother left our small town in Europe to seek a better life in NYC. She promised she would take me and my grandma with her as soon as she could. The next time I saw her I was 17. We moved to a small apartment building with no elevator in Brooklyn. My mother told me she got married to a younger guy and was expecting a child. She told me that she told everybody including her husband that I was her sister and not her daughter. She also told me that her husband would divorce her if he found out she had kids. 10 months later my mother had a baby and them another baby boy. I and my grandma were helping her with the kids 6 days a week. We adored them. 7 years passed. Kids were calling me their aunt. On my constant question of what I should tell them, my mother told me that the truth should die with us. About 8 months ago I noticed that my mother was getting very irritated and constantly angry. She would pick up a meaningless fight and every time I would try to tell her something contrary of what she thought, she would tell me that I wouldn't see the kids. One day we had a fight and I was told that I would never see the kids. I was very hurt as well as my grandma. I decided that I shouldn't call my mother for sometime so that she would understand that she couldn't manipulate me with the kids. 6 months passed without talking. Not a single phone call to me nor my grandma who is 69 years old with heart condition. I was taking care of my grandma as well as supporting her financilly in full. I saw that my grandma was suffering without seeing the kids. She would talk about them all the time. One day she went to their school so that she could see them for at leat 5 min. I couldn't take that situation anymore. I called my mother and suggested what we didn't argue anymore. She agreed but told me that her husband was against us seeing the kids. When I tried to call him, she interfered and told me that he hated me and that he didn't want to talk to me again. When I told her that I never had an arguement with him, she told me that he hated me because I was trying to break their family. I told her that all I wanted was for my grandma and me to see the kids because we loved them. She refused to allow us to see them. She suggested that we shouldn't talk for some time. I think it's important to know that I'm 28 years old now, young professional who fully supports myself and my grandma. I was recently engaged to a very nice guy. He thinks my mother is my sister. I live in the world of lies. I can't even tell him nor my friends of what is happening with my family. I'm very scared about what is going to happen to the kids in the future. My mother can betray them as she betrayed me. Should I just leave her alone and never talk to her or should I fight for kids visitations for their sake? I'm about to start my own family. Should I tell my future husband the truth? I'm embarassed and hurt. Please help. Thank you


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

8 Posted Answers
Order by

 
4552 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi,
Wow.... you can easily write a book and sure it will be a best seller.....  Here are several practical advises / observations:
1.  Don't argue with your mother. 
2.  She lives in a world of lies.
3.  You were part of that world of lies.
     (without willing).
4.  It's clear that you want to establish
     normal loving relations with your
     (half) brothers.
5.  For some unexplained reason your
     mother's husband doesn't want you
     in his (+famaly) life. 
6.  Consequently: You can't fullfil your
     wishes / desires.  Disconnect all
     relations with all of them and hope
     that something goog will occour in
     the future. 
7.  Concentrate on to your new life and
     create a warm loving family.
8.  Tell your husband the whole truth
     exactly as it is.  Don't hide from
     him even 1 single detail. 
9.  Tell him that he must be confidential 
     since it is a very sensetive issue that
     if revealed can cause much damage.
10.  You are an outstanding person !. 
God bless you !!!!!
    

Posted 2008-06-01T10:28:30Z
Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer
 
8 helpful answers

We're gonna be here awhile, so we might as well turn on some tunes !!

Your mother has done you a terrible injustice, but nonetheless, she is your mother.  For one thing, stop lying for her.  Its not your problem anymore that she had to lie to her husband.  It never was in the first place, but certainly not now.  You COULD use that for leverage in attempting to see the kids. 

As far as telling your fiance the truth, Absolutely.  Do not let your mom's deeds mess up your future.  she messed up your childhood.  Don't give her any more control over your life.  Tell him and if he really loves you, he will want to help you and he will totally understand.  Wouldn't you rather he found out from you?  I know you are embarassed and scared, but honey, you can't pick your parents.  You didn't do anything wrong.  You were abused emotionally and a victim of your environment.    Hold you head up and make your future wonderful, wonderful, wonderful.  You deserve it.

God bless you.  You sound like a very caring and forgiving person.  Pray and God will give you the strength you need.  I promise you.

 

Posted 2008-06-01T13:48:13Z
Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer
 
2441 helpful answers

 

 

Hi Stacy,

     What a story you just told,  so sorry that you suffered emotionally for a long time because of your mother's lies.  You don't need to be a part of that.  Tell your boyfriend everything that had happened and if he loves you enough, he won't get upset because you did not fabricate the situation.  Start a new life with this man and do things differently now, no lies, everything should be done honestly.  Then you don't have to worry about anything when you tell the truth.

     With regards to your mom, never contact her again.  She has her own life to live  You need to concentrate on your own life.

     Hopefully everything will turn out OK for you.  You deserve it.  Here's wishing you a lifetime of happiness.  Take care.

Posted 2008-06-01T20:31:03Z
Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer
 
1 helpful answer

Thank you for your help. I truely appreciate it.

Posted 2008-06-02T14:58:10Z
Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer
 
1 helpful answer

I appreciate your help. Thank you

Posted 2008-06-02T15:21:44Z
 
1 helpful answer

Thank you. Your advice feels so right.

 

Posted 2008-06-02T15:44:28Z
 
1 helpful answer

I want to thank you again for a great answer.  Disconnecting myself from my mother is definitely the only choice I have. However, my only fear is that my mother will make my half brothers life miserable because people don't change. Could you advise anything as far as contacting them when they'll be 12-15? Should I ever contact them to tell them the truth? My thinking is that I want them to know that they can lean on me if they be in a similar situation or at least they'll know that I exist?

Posted 2008-06-02T19:34:51Z
 
13 helpful answers

For your own self preservation, I disagree with never talking to your mother. Let your mother know your door is always open to her. If Mom chooses not to talk to you, then there is little or nothing you can do about that. I do agree however, you must come clean with your husband -to -be. Ask that he never discuss this private family matter with anyone other than you. As far as lying, I would never lie for anyone, just say nothing and/or when asked, direct any and all questions of a private nature to your mom. You need to set boundries with your mother for your own sanity.

If something were to happen to your mother, you will carry the burden of guilt, for the rest of your life. So don't cut your mom out of your life. You cannot control what your mom does, you can only control what you do.

You will be fine once you institute boundries and if she never contacts you again, it will be her choice and not yours. So you will have no guilt. Your mother can never doubt your love, if you continue to show her love. But you are grown now and you have a life of your own to live. So get on with your life, be happy and set boundries with family. But don't cut family out of your life. As far as telling the kids, there will be an approprite time to do that.  Grandma and the kids will be proud of the way you handled this very private family matter. God Bless You. Your situation in  so many ways mirrors my life. My Mother has passed and I loved her, only as she would let me. I am still here, living my life, raising my kids and doing it with no regrets. Speaking of disfunctional familes. Someone  once told me that if we can do just 10% better than our parents , then we can consider ourself a sucess. I am proud of the way I dealt with my family.  I do not want to leave my children the legacy of disfunction.

P.S. I am sure the kids will be ok. Keep a positive attitude, no need to worry yourself sick about something that has not happen yet.

 My Prayers and God's Blessing for you.

Posted 2008-06-02T20:41:56Z
missymolly was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(2)
Rated as Best Answer

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for stacy? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog

Explore Related Tips

Charm Pack Tote: Sewing Tutorial

Today’s feature is from Buttonberry with this Charm Pack Tote: blockquote>If you can’t get charm packs then it’s not a problem – you can cut your own squares! You’ll need about 1 yard of fabric in total but try to use at least 2 different prints – more for a really shabby chic, “scrappy” look! This sweet tote [...] Also See These Tips: The Weekender Tote: Sewing Tutorial Quick & Easy Spring Tote Tutorial Pillowcase Tote – Sewing Tutorial

Rose Petal Sachet: {Crochet Pattern}

Here’s a little sachet that’s perfect to give as a stocking stuffer for someone who loves frilly, Victorian style pretties. It’s been a long time since I’ve tried my hand at thread crochet but this whipped up in no time for me (although a bit wonky in a spot or two). he sample sachet pictured to [...] Also See These Tips: Vintage Pincushion Sachet: Crochet Pattern Turban Head Scarf: Vintage Crochet Pattern Bun Warmer Linen: Vintage Crochet Edging Pattern

50 Appetizer Recipes & Party Pleasers

I’m always on the lookout for new recipes to treat party guests with a tasty appetizer or hors d’oeuvre and this list is going to keep me busy (and guests smiling). This week’s Recipe Hit List is a packed bunch of 50 crowd pleasing appetizers that I’ve handpicked from around the ‘net: some easy (some [...] Also See These Tips: 150+ Superbowl Party Recipes 12 Pasta Recipe Pleasers 10 Tempting Sweet Treats: Recipes

Homemade Vanilla Oil: How-To

Use vanilla oil for any recipe requiring vegetable oil (cooking, baking, vinaigrettes), it will add a nice vanilla kick to your dish. It’s so quick and easy to make, here’s how: How To Make Homemade Vanilla Oil strong>Ingredients: 1 vanilla bean 2 cups vegetable oil Directions: Cut open the vanilla bean and scrape out the seeds. Warm oil on top of the [...] Also See These Tips: Homemade Vanilla Sugar Recipes Homemade Vanilla Extract: Recipes & Tips Vanilla & Cloves Air Freshener Spray – Recipe

DIY: Wall Mounted Magnetic Spice Rack

Today’s feature is from The Kitchn with this tutorial for How To Make a Wall-Mounted Magnetic Spice Rack: blockquote> This homemade wall-mounted spice rack David created for his kitchen. Read on for details on how he did it, and links to all the equipment you’d need to recreate this in your own kitchen. The tutorial is very basic [...] Also See These Tips: DIY Spice Rack Pretty Magnetic Knife Rack DIY Laundry Room Drying Rack

Vintage Embroidery: Tableware Pattern #3

Here is this week’s free pattern from the Vintage Embroidery Tableware set, this pattern features assorted items such as a plate, covered dish and a few sprays of flowers. Free Pattern Download You can download this week’s pattern here: Tableware Pattern #3 Printing Instructions: Save the pattern to your desktop first (right click, save as…), open the file, select [...] Also See These Tips: Vintage Embroidery: Tableware Pattern #2 Vintage Embroidery Kitchen Towel Set: Tableware Bluebird Cross Stitch & Embroidery Pattern: Sunday

DIY Pom-Pom Lamp: Tutorial

Today’s feature is from Ruffles And Stuff with this tutorial for a Practically Free Pom-Pom Lamp: blockquote>Unfortunately these pictures don’t do justice to this lamp at all! It’s so pretty when the lights are low! It reminds me of those dandelions that kids love to blow on ) How sweet is that! All you need for [...] Also See These Tips: How To Make A Teapot Lamp How To Make An Olive Oil Lamp Paper Mache Party Lights: Crafty Project

Kitchen Q&A: Is It Ok To Reuse Cooking...

This week’s Kitchen Q & A tackles questions on reusing cooking oil, if there’s a difference between white and brown eggs, testing the temperature in your oven (and refrigerator), how to darken gravy and more! Kitchen Q&A: Is It Ok To Reuse Cooking Oil? (And More) ol> Is it ok to reuse cooking oil after deep frying? Deep [...] Also See These Tips: Darken Gravy Tricks & Gravy Enhancer Recipes 25 Vintage Cooking Tips: Timeless Wisdom Why a Cake Fails

Sewing Organizer Tutorial

Today’s feature is from FlossieBlossoms with this Sewing Organizer Tutorial: blockquote>Kitten (Kid?) Proof Sewing Organizer for Sofa or Travel Please feel free to make these for yourself or for gifts or to sell locally, but I’d appreciate it if you didn’t sell them on Etsy as I intend to put some in my shop there. Thanks! The tutorial [...] Also See These Tips: Wallet Sized Sewing Kit – Free Tutorial Bed Caddy Organizer: {Sewing} Purse Organizer – Sewing Tutorial
» More...
Powered by
ADVERTISEMENT
Tipnut Q&A is powered by Yedda an AOL Company
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners