• Answers
  • Web

Man who lives in glass house dresses in basement

 

Are JEWS a RACE?

Are JEWS a RACE?


I took a Jewish history classes at Carnegie Mellon University. I received a "C" for arguing this with a professor about this one issue, even though I did all my work creatively and efficiently. The professor was even a friend of my grandmothers (because of this I won't use her name). She was wrong and she should not of graded me accordingly. Jewish history can be looked at from many different perspectives and it is unfortunate that CMU used this woman as a tool. It is not surprising to see Palestinian slants coming from Humanity and Arts departments at CMU these days. My teacher and other Jews like her set the precedent for future intolerance by refusing to budge on issues coming out of the Holocaust.  The goal of the Jewish people as is the Christian people is a worldwide Zion.  The juxtaposition of how this Zion occurs is a matter of contention, but both faiths believe in the accession of a greater global government called Israel.  The people who started this movement were called Jews.  They are in fact closely related to each other and are debatably a "RACE".  Christians maintain that this government will come with the acceptance of they're leader, and therefor Christians are a part of this same Zion.  Jews believe that they're future leader will come and some like myself believe that the scripture is misleading and that while there will be key leaders, that this Zion will come through the actions of people and the details of the messiah will be unknown till it is known and obvious. Regardless of the slant on Zion, the end conclusion of Zionism is a belief in key people who are of close genetic relation and the people's they friend.  Converts of Judaism become not only part of a philosophy, but part of the physical "People" in that the hope is that they're blood will mingle into a Jewish gene pool.   It is also part of Christian theology... a concept of the Christian people and Republic, with the Juxtaposition that Israel will become part of this Christian Zionist Republic.  This is not Fascism, nor  is it bigotry.  The very reason both cultures have a process of conversion is to keep the people from being elitist and therefor racist.  The State of Israel is not the final Zion.  The modern state of Israel is a defense to keep the people alive to embrace the coming evolution.  It is in fact a necessary compromise, because the next evolution of Israel will be global.  It is very possible that the people of Israel might might be destroyed and the people executed and that a new genetic group with the same philosophy could rise from the ashes and become the new Israel. (however I feel like I am making some kind of Hollywood movie when I talk like this)


Racism itself is a term that developed recently.  Race generally concerns the color of a person's skin.  It is a silly term.  The Jewish concept of RACE is a more beautiful embrace of difference then the silly dynamic of BLACK, WHITE, BROWN, RED, YELLOW, in that the Jewish concept of RACE is inclusive.  That is not to say there aren't some horrible exceptions to this and perhaps that is why ZION has not arrived yet.  My best friend is a Yemenite Jew.  He looks like the people of KUSH culture.  His skin is dark and I would have no issue mingling so to speak genetically with some of his beautiful dark skinned relatives.  I would have no issue with any of my family having dark skinned children, and in fact I do have dark skinned relatives on my mother's side.

---------------------------------------------
twitteratti are horrible... it's like anywhere else....

IRONICALLY THIS HAPPENED ON MARTIN LUTHER KING DAY!

Nazis expect every JEW to be a philosopher...
lucky for me I am well read and educated... I actually gave an intelligent answer... but the simple fact of the matter is if someone insists on knowing if JEWS are a religion or a culture/religion... it is neither and it is both.
It can be one thing for one person and another for another.
language insists on declaring JEWS as not a RACE because of Hitler... but that is incorrect, because the vast majority of us are related.... or as related as say BLACK people are who mix as well.... point being is that RACE is a human construct, designed to help us deal with generalities that are real. That doesn't always mean we can define things uniformly.

JEWS are a RACE and also not a RACE...
but for this angry dude that answer was unacceptable.

intolerance comes from not being able to objectify people. Intolerance comes from finding something out of a classification that one is used to. This guy with all his arrogance was a classic BIGOT. I am amazed the people on TWITTER let this happen. Like a line in the sand as in UN 242, classifying is designed to help, but it is not a classification that is beyond exception. I understand how frustrating it can be for people to not have things uniform and convenient, but human relations and also language evolves and defies this kind of determined bias.

People like things to stay the same... but they don't. The classification of what we consider to be BLACK or WHITE, Jew or Gentile will evolve. Most of what we have dealt with over the last century is a reflection of HITLER's convenient classification of an enemy, but that does not mean that most JEWS are not genetically related to each other. To call some one a RACIST for hating JEWS is fair game... and that classification can change as well.
 
the TWITTER conversation is here for your analysis
http://simonstudiotheatre.blogspot.com/2008/04/mlk-day-pests.html 
Are JEWS a RACE?  What is your slant on this?
 
 
 


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

19 Posted Answers
Order by

 
There are horrible little people here. Watch out!
(deleted account)

Gerldine1... I was just reading through some your answers, and this one stifled me.  You say that the Jewish People have "NEVER PROMOTED HATRED".  This comment begs to ask you..   Do you you Believe that Jesus was murdered for your Sins?  And if you do Believe that, who do you think Murded Him???

 
37 helpful answers

Man who lives in glass house dresses in basement

 

 
There are horrible little people here. Watch out!
(deleted account)

I've read all these responses.. out of curiosity, and it got me to wondering.  Some say that you are Jewish because your Mother is Jewish, it's in your blood-line, so then becomes your Religion, as if 'automatically', 'of coarse'.   What I'm wondering about that belief is.. I was born with American Indian blood in me from my Mothers side.  American Indians have a Culture of their own, very strong Spiritual Beliefs, that I don't follow or even believe in.  Am I wrong for straying from my heritage?  Are there things I am 'supposed to Believe in' no matter how I truely feel because I am an American Indian?

Helpful?(0)
Rated #12 out of 19
 
You have deleted this post. It will not be visible to other users. Restore this post
There are horrible little people here. Watch out!
(deleted account)

SimonStudio.. you really are very funny,. My Husband likes your comment.  By the way, isn't Mel Gibson Jewish?

 
37 helpful answers

Man who lives in glass house dresses in basement

 

ask a question somewhere else and link to it.  Mel Gibson isn't jewish.  

 

My son is part native American as well as part Jewish.  It will be up to him to find what he believes in. Judaism is a philosophy and a genetic group of people (arguable a race).  The important part is not that issue.  But there is definitely a gene pool of Jews and a community... but you are welcome to join us genetically through marriage and spiritually through conversion.  The important part is one g-d without any complicated details or divisions.  The goal is a utopic existence brought on through a unifying state that reflects g-d.  Todays Judaism realizes this through a Democratic Republic with boundaries that will grow through free will.  The hope is that America will also be part of this Zionist Republic, but in the mean time we will never force convert.

 The majority Christian point of view is very similar with the one hope that the messiah be recognized as a Jewish leader who died two thousand years ago due to our communities involvement with Rome.  It is the majority Jewish opinion that this was a mistake and most of us recognize Joshua as a great non elitist teacher who was misunderstood by everyone.  My opinion is that he was misunderstood in his day, and I feel it is arrogant to assume we understand him today.

Posted 2008-06-15T10:49:11Z
 
1 helpful answer

Genetic evidence shows that Jews are merely Palastanians who migrated from the highlands to the plains of Judea.  DNA proves everything and it does not agree with much in the bible.

Helpful?(0)
Rated #11 out of 19
 
37 helpful answers

Man who lives in glass house dresses in basement

 

you are looking for a fight and you won't get one Bill.  no bible believing person disputes that the Hebrews and their neighbors are related.  This compounded that Judea is only 1/12th of Israel... and you have a lot of complications just in the biblical perspective (post Abraham)

Helpful?(0)
Rated #13 out of 19
 
12 helpful answers

From the Websters Dictionary: n., pl. -naz·im (-n?z'?m, -nä'z?m).

A member of the branch of European Jews, historically Yiddish-speaking, who settled in central and northern Europe from Poland, Russia and Khazaria. Any of the historically Yiddish-speaking European Jews who settled in central and northern Europe, or their descendants. They lived originally in the Rhineland valley, and their name is derived from the Hebrew word Ashkenaz ("Germany"). After the start of the Crusades in the late 11th century, many migrated east to Poland, Lithuania, and Russia to escape persecution. In later centuries Jews who adopted the German-rite synagogue ritual were called Ashkenazim to differentiate them from the Sephardic, or Spanish-rite, Jews (see Sephardi), from whom they differ in cultural traditions, pronunciation of Hebrew, and synagogue chanting as well as in the use of the Yiddish language (until the 20th century). Today they constitute more than 80% of the world's Jews.

Actually- being an Israelite IS a race of people. Just like if you are MEXICAN- you are a race of people. Meaning the same BLOODLINE. The "JEWS" of today are not of the Shemitic bloodline, therefore they are not Israelites. They are JEWS and Israelis- which is not a race but rather a RELIGION that a race of Khazars from the line of Japheth created in Germany, Poland, etc. This is why you can "convert" to "become" a Jew. One cannot "convert" to become black or Hawaiian. You either are or you are not. You are either from the tribe of Judah, or you are not. The tribe of Judah comes from Shem. The Ashkenazi Jews claim bloodline to Japheth.

Ashkenaz is the medieval Hebrew name for the region which in modern times encompasses the country of Germany and German-speaking borderland areas. Ashkenaz is also a Japhetic patriarch in the Table of Nations (Genesis 10).

To underscore this, they did not speak Hebrew, but rather created a NEW language (Yiddish) and a NEW name (Jews not Israelite or Hebrew)  and a NEW book (The Talmud).

With them, they took and diversified Yiddish, a Germanic  language that had since medieval times been the lingua franca among Ashkenazi Jews.

Please dont say I am being bigoted. This is just plain fact. Research the word Ashkenazi- and you will plainly see. Being and Israelite from the tribe of Judah (where the created the term Jew from) means that you are of the bloodline of Shem and Judah. If you are not, then you are not Judaic. Much love to all.

Helpful?(0)
Rated #14 out of 19

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for SimonStudio? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Do you think Obama shows his true colors toward Israel, Jews and Christians?

Do you think obama shows his true colors toward israel, jews and christians? Obama shows his true colors toward israel, jews ...
Submitted by Socialism Sucks   4 months ago.
  • viewed 262 times
Last answer posted 2 months ago by Diaz Cordova


Explore Related Posts in Forums

Islam Or Christianity Or Judaism

Muslim, Jew, Christian or others? What do you think of the current affairs between the US and Iraq , and the Palestine and Israel? a Muslim. Are we allowed to talk about politics in these forums? They usually cause problems

Any Israelis here? I'd like to hear firsthand an explanation of why the...

I'm not trying to start a thread-war, but I don't understand Israel's policies. If I were born in Israel and had the opportunity to, I would get out of there as fast as possible. I would move . It's not only Islam. Christianity had it's own religious war "just war", and it's the same

Christian supporters of Israel gar in Washington (Why does Israel seek...

Not all extremist Christians are kooks. And, as a Jew, assuming reddit is any barometer, I think its Israel needs all of the support it can get. are the Jews who convert to Christianity and avoid being cast into the Lake of Fire. They base
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License