What's bubbling in your head? (SM)

Israel and Hamas

Why didn't Israel kick the crap out of Hamas when it had the chance? What would have happened if they took out Nasrallah during his public appearance last week?


Would you like to answer or comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).
  • 594 views
Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

Posted Answers

Order by
 
154 thumbs up

In effect, Israel never did really have a chance to "kick the crap out of Hamas" (or eliminate them, in other words). Israel has already assassinated several Hamas leaders in the past (most famous are Ahmed Yassin, and Abdel Aziz Al-Rantisi). These assassinations might have arguably harmed Hamas' capabilities for some period, but was far from totally incapacitating it. In fact, some may argue the assassinations only made Hamas more popular within the Palestininans, which led to their victory in the 2006 elections.

This also apply when asking why didn't Israel assassinate Nasrallah at his first public appearance after the war. It its most likely that by doing so, Israel had more to lose than to gain. It is highly unlikely that Israel could really eliminate the Hezbolla by killing Nasrallah. On the other side, this would probably re-ignite the violence between the two sides, and get Israel condemned by the international community.


Posted 2 years ago ( permalink )
In reply to SodaHead's question
Rated as
#2 out of 2
0
0

Helpful?

line
line
line



 

The way I see it, nearly the entire world is extremely aware of Israel's military abilities. People on both sides are, or at least, were, convinced that Israel has the capabilities to eliminate any possible threat to it. In my opinion, there are two major factors preventing this.

  • International Opinion: Israel has always longed to be a fully accepted member of the global community. As a developed country, Israel is held back by the numerous international charters is has joined. Existing in such a politically volatile area, while being the only fully democratic government in the area, exposes Israeli actions to both international and internal scrutiny in its dealings. Poor international representation (the fabled hasbara) had led to a global conviction of Israel being a bully. Israel is suffering from what is known as a "weaker strong country". Think America's failure in Iraq. Israel cannot use its strength against a guerilla army.
  • Lack of internal cohesiveness: Israel has become a neo-liberalistic democracy. Valuing human rights (which is in itself, obviously a good thing) has overshadowed the raison de' etre. When a state can no longer freely act in its defense and suffers from internal issues, it cannot commit itself to defense. A poorly created defensive strategy, a lack of initiative and too many "doves" held back Israel's hand. Ironically, this will make Israel appear weaker, bolstering Nasrallah's confidence and undoubtedly leading to more and more skirmishes to look forward to. Yay.

Posted 2 years ago ( permalink )
In reply to SodaHead's question
Rated as
Best Answer
0
1

Helpful?

line
line
line



Sign in to participate

Got an answer for SodaHead? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Fighting In Lebanon

Is the new fighting in Lebanon going to spark a civil war and do you think it will spread to Israel?
Submitted by taligat 5 months ago
  • viewed 250 times

Last answer posted 5 months ago by profitbob


Palin's child is NOT her child....

Has anyone else noticed the story that just popped up about how Palin's child with down syndrome is NOT her child, but instead her ...
Submitted by geniusprofit 1 month ago
  • viewed 379 times

Last answer posted 2 days ago by triLcat


Why does the rest of the *world* fail to believe ...

Why does the rest of the *world* fail to believe he means what he says?
Submitted by Jo Anne 14 days ago
  • viewed 69 times

Last answer posted 4 days ago by triLcat



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

I am so tired of "Israel lost" garbage, Nasrallah is jealous

NON hezbollah troops in south lebanon for years? Israel. What troops are there now? NON hezbollah I am so sick of this Israeli lost garbage, as I said in the old forum, Israel has won. Who wanted

Nasrallah afraid of US in Lebanon

campaign in Lebanon applies equally to the Gaza-based jihadist group’s offensive against Israel. DEBKAfile: Hizballah head warns Lebanon and Arab world not to tangle with al Qaeda on US behalf

Nasrallah at war with Lebanon

as Hezbollah says Lebanon 'declares war' by Jocelyne Zablit 10 minutes ago BEIRUT (AFP) - Deadly gunbattles erupted in Beirut on Thursday after Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah charged that a Lebanese
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog

Explore Related Videos

Israel Troupe Senior HL

These clips are Senior highlights of current UGA wide receiver Israel Troupe when he was at Tift County High School in Tifton, Georgia. Thanks dshx - NCAA Football - Georgia Bulldogs - Israel Troupe

Imagine 2018 Israel

OneVoice Israel worked with 250 local schools across Israel, 20 municipality education centers in major cities, a number of youth magazines and internet forums, the Tel Aviv Cinamathique, as well as Tzofim, Noar Oved, Shomar Tzair, and Mhanot Haolim youth movements to bring the imagine: 2018 essay contest to youth from all over Israel. The contest launched on 16 March and ran through mid-June, and was open to all school children aged 13-18 throughout Israel. OneVoice Israel accepted submissions on its own website, through the largest internet forum in Israel (Tapuz), through the heads of cinema chapters at 250 different schools, and through the youth movements with which it is partnering. In addition, OneVoice staff and volunteers went from school to school to talk about the contest and encourage youth to participate. School teachers and administrators chose one semi-finalist per school; the leaders of each youth movement will select ten essays from their pool; and the OneVoice Israel staff and board have selected a total of forty semi-finalists from among the internet submissions. Another round of judging narrowed the pool to a total of 50 winners by 30 June 2008. Essays were judged based on clarity and creativity, in addition to the potential of the essay to motivate others to take action toward ending the conflict. An event honoring the winners will be held in the late summer. OneVoice Israel is exploring the potential of partnering with an organization called Cinemathique for this event to raise the profile. All 50 winning essays will be published in a booklet, to be presented to the Israeli governmental leadership. Additionally, the winners' essays will be entered into the pool of applicants for the imagine: 2018 Director's Cut.

Imagine 2018 IL

OneVoice Israel worked with 250 local schools across Israel, 20 municipality education centers in major cities, a number of youth magazines and internet forums, the Tel Aviv Cinamathique, as well as Tzofim, Noar Oved, Shomar Tzair, and Mhanot Haolim youth movements to bring the imagine: 2018 essay contest to youth from all over Israel. The contest launched on 16 March and ran through mid-June, and was open to all school children aged 13-18 throughout Israel. OneVoice Israel accepted submissions on its own website, through the largest internet forum in Israel (Tapuz), through the heads of cinema chapters at 250 different schools, and through the youth movements with which it is partnering. In addition, OneVoice staff and volunteers went from school to school to talk about the contest and encourage youth to participate. School teachers and administrators chose one semi-finalist per school; the leaders of each youth movement will select ten essays from their pool; and the OneVoice Israel staff and board have selected a total of forty semi-finalists from among the internet submissions. Another round of judging narrowed the pool to a total of 50 winners by 30 June 2008. Essays were judged based on clarity and creativity, in addition to the potential of the essay to motivate others to take action toward ending the conflict. An event honoring the winners will be held in the late summer. OneVoice Israel is exploring the potential of partnering with an organization called Cinemathique for this event to raise the profile. All 50 winning essays will be published in a booklet, to be presented to the Israeli governmental leadership. Additionally, the winners' essays will be entered into the pool of applicants for the imagine: 2018 Director's Cut.

Estado de Israel - Segundo Programa- Bloque 1

En este programa y siempre de la mano de S.E. el Señor Embajador de Israel en la Argentina Rafael Eldad, conversaremos sobre negocios, sobre oportunidades mutuas y veremos la base tecnológica y de desarrollo que ofrece Israel. Tampoco hemos rehuido los temas dolorosos, las heridas que en nuestra piel Argentina han producido los atentados contra la Embajada de Israel y en especial contra la AMIA, donde murieron no solo israelíes... murieron argentinos

Columbia shuttle astronaut's diary goes on...

5 Oct 08: Pages from an Israeli astronaut's diary, that survived the explosion of the space shuttle Columbia, went on display today at the Israel Museum.

Kyle Israel, Arizona Injury & Wrongful...

Kyle A. Israel and his associates handle personal injury and wrongful death cases at Israel & Gerity PLLC in Phoenix, Arizona. They personally handle your case and go after responsible parties to get you compensation for your loss. Dont let insurance companies ignore you. Call Israel & Gerity PLLC, Attorneys-at-Law for a consultation. Visit us http://www.yellowpages.com/info-IY248659346/Kyle-Israel-Arizona-Injury-Wrongful-Death-Attorney/?auto_play=true

Why There Is No Palestine

The Israeli/Palestinian conflict is the defining crisis of our era. Like the Pyramid Wars of old, it is a struggle between rival cosmological hypotheses. Ultimately, one must choose between the Jews and the Muslims, or be a trivial observer to this eras epic drama. If one believes in the Elohim described in the Old Testament, one must conclude that the Jews are the rightful inhabitants of the Biblically-defined land of Israel. In all things exist opposing polarities, opposing orientations. This is the nature of life. In the heavens, as in the psyche of man, are these opposing forces at play. Yahweh, the god of the old testament, represents a synthesis of these opposing forces, and therefore represents a level of cosmic neutrality. More explicitly, Yahweh is derived from combining Enki and Enlil, the two prime contenders for dominion of the earth in the Sumerian stories. One who is intuitive enough to sense divine existence, and reasonable enough to apply logic, will ultimately seek Sumers explanatory wisdom. Those whose psyches reflect the neutrality of Yahweh must inhabit the zone declared neutral in the ancient struggle between opposing cosmic forces. The Jews who seek to build the Third Temple and conduct animal sacrifice therein are those truly worthy to dwell in the presence of the Elohim. Note how Orthodox Jews can be found in support of various sides of tremendously polarizing issues, thereby demonstrating a neutrality worthy of Yahweh. To properly set the stage for the coming of those in whose image we were created, The Jews must have unimpeded inhabitation of Israel and the Temple must be built. This is why the existence of a Palestinian homeland within the borders of Biblically-defined Israel is a blasphemy against the intentions of the heavens. This does not speak either for or against the notion of Jewish global domination. All viable groups struggle for domination. Nonetheless, the primacy of Jerusalem as the international seat of Elohimic authority must be respected. Within Elohimic authority, as within the psyche informed by the presence of such authority, there exists both Heaven and Hell. Both will need be unleashed to secure the most worthy of objectives.

Especial Infolive.tv: Caras de Israel -...

Shulamit vive en Jerusalén, tiene 19 años y presta su servicio nacional en el Museo Israel. Sus padres inmigraron de Rusia. En esta edición de las Caras de Israel, ella habla con nosotros sobre su vida y sus proyectos. 07/10/08

Ahmadinejad 'The idea of a smaller Israel...

This is a combination of two addresses that the mutant ninja turtle gave on Iranian television in late September. I wonder if he would agree with the proposition that if the 'Palestinians' can go after 'settlers' as 'human shields,' the IDF can go after Gaza civilians as human shields. Hmmm. Following are excerpts from statements made by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, which aired on IRINN, the Iranian News Channel, on September 18 and 23, 2008. Let's go to the videotape. A transcript follows: September 18, 2008 Mahmoud Ahmadinejad: The Zionists are crooks. A small handful of Zionists, with a very intricate organization, have taken over the power centers of the world. According to our estimates, the main cadre of the Zionists consists of 2,000 individuals at most, and they have another 8,000 activists. In addition, they have several informants, who spy and provide them with intelligence information. But because of their control of power centers in the U.S. and Europe, and their control of the financial centers and the news and propaganda agencies, they spread propaganda as if they were the entire world, as if all the peoples supported them, and as if they were the majority ruling the world. That is a great lie just like their Jewishness is a great lie. They have no religion whatsoever. They are a handful of lying, power-greedy people who have no religion, who only want to take over all the peoples and countries, and to trample the rights of the peoples. [...] I've heard that one of them [PM Olmert] recently said that the idea of Greater Israel is dead. I would like to declare that the idea of "smaller Israel" is also dead. The very notion of Israel is dead, but they are lagging behind the times. Just like the idea of Greater Israel died 30 years ago, and they did not realize this, and have continued to perpetrate crimes for 30 years... Today, I say to them: The idea of smaller Israel is dead. Let me give them a piece of advice: You would be better off if you stop your oppression and express remorse. If you want to do something good in your lives, leave the land of Palestine, free it from your oppression and occupation. Carry on with your lives. You captivated [Jewish] people with your trickery and lies, and you brought them over there with false promises. You sent them to settlements in order to serve as your human shields, and you continue to perpetrate your crimes. Let me give you some advice: Enough. For 60 years, you have been doing ugly things and committing crimes leave, and show remorse. [...] You've heard on the news that [the Zionists] established a network for kidnapping people. They kidnap oppressed, destitute, ignorant people from other countries, and bring them to the occupied lands to serve as human shields. [...] If the occupiers and invaders take ignorant people even if they are innocent and use them as human shields in order to carry out invasions, the [Palestinian] people, which is on the defensive, has to conduct resistance, even if it is against innocent people, who were brought to the scene without being aware of it. [...] At this very moment, hundreds of American exporters are trying very hard to sell products to Iran, but we refuse. The same goes for investors from some European countries that you mentioned, who insist on investing in Iran but we set conditions. [...] September 23, 2008 You [the West] cut off some of our TV and radio satellite channels, which brought the message of the Iranian people to some other nations. You thought that the Iranian people would be helpless, but I want to tell you that today, the Iranian people has the technology to build all kinds of satellites, and with the help of God, it will launch its first communications and remote-sensing satellite into space. [...] A Zionist organization with 2,000 [members] and with 7,000 or 8,000 activists have brought the world to a state of confusion. Let me tell them that if they themselves do not wrap up Zionism, the strong arm of the peoples will wipe these germs of corruption off the face of the earth. Kind of makes the idea of an international forum in which Israel and Iran can talk to each other ludicrous, doesn't it? I wonder how Ahmadinejad deals with the demons he obviously sees all over the place.
» More...
Powered by