There are many good carriers, first seek the advise from a local independent agent, check with neighbors and friends for a reccomendation. Be sure your are insuring the home for the reconstruction cost not market value. If you have a high end Home of $1,000,000 or more seek a carrier such as CHUBB who specializes in the high end home. You may also wish to place your auto coverage to bundle the home/auto with the same carrier, which will provide a multi-policy discount. Also to consider if you are on a coastal property you may also be required to obtain flood insurance. Most direct writer offer little in the way of advise as they only know of one way, their comopany way which may not be what you need. Seek the advise from a professional insurance agent, most represent many carriers so that they can match you to the correct carrier for the coverage needed, and the premium at a competitive priceing.