• Answers
  • Web

I invited some of my grandchildren to our home to ...

I invited some of my grandchildren to our home to give our children some hours of quiet. All was going well until one of the older children hit a younger one and made him cry. I immediately hit the older child showing him that a blow that he gave his cousin really hurts. When his parents came to pick him up he told them what I did and now they are not talking to me. Wouldn't you agree that the older child needed immediate disciple or perhaps should I have waited for the parents?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

5 Posted Answers
Order by

 
4653 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi Brosen, ------------ I hope that I can say my words open and firect: You made a terrible mistake: A grandfather should never hit his granchildren (well, unless it's a MUST, like life saving). I know it's hard at certain moments but all you can and should do is bitr your lips and hold your hand..... I'll be even more extreme: not even shout at them.... The most you could do when it happened is tell that child that he / she very dissapointed you and require an official appology (+ a promise it will nevert happen again). Dicipline and education is only the rights of their parents.... and you can only advise (not an inch beyond it). No wonder they are angry with you. Sorry, but that's the truth. --------------- Best regards,

Posted 2008-08-31T10:49:04Z
 
36 helpful answers

Hello,

 

A sticky situation to be sure. It's hard to know what to do but it is always easy to second guess a decision and tell someone what they should have done, don't you agree ?

 

I am not an advocate of physical punishment since in effect you have just done to the child the very thing you were trying to tell them was wrong.  Perhaps his parents were upset because they feel the same way ? Hard to say without all the back ground information. Give them a bit of time to calm down, then offer an explanation and an apology and put the matter to rest.

 

My personal feeling is that everyone, parents, grandparents, aunts uncles, extended family can and should be responsible for a child's upbringing which includes punishment if needed.  When I was small we lived in a very small town and not only did everyone watch out for one another, but we also were not able to get away with anything !  The phone would be ringing before we even got home to inform my grandmother that we had been seen snapping the roses off of Mr Worley's prize bushes, etc etc.   Now it's more like " don't you dare say my child did that" with no one taking responsibility for or accepting the task for properly raising a child. Which does, again in my opinion, take more the just the parents. It involves the entire family, teachers, pastors, etc etc.

 

You did what you felt was right at the time as many of us do. Now try to understand why your children feel the way they do and resolve the situation before it turns into a life long affair.

 

Good Luck !

Posted 2008-08-31T12:21:46Z
Helpful?(10)
Rated as Best Answer
 
4 helpful answers

I am like churches chicken baby ... you gotta love me!

Wow... YOu keep your grandchildren for your children to have quiet time? that is awesome... I am a mother of three and my parents NEVER keep my kids for me!  I don't think you did wrong.  I am always begging my mom to disipline my kids.  I grew up with her whooping my behind and I don't think we should stop with this generation.  Physical disipline is begining to be less and less accepted these days and our kids are also getting more and more misbehaived.  "time out" and other methods are just dumb.  I think you did what you had to do at the time and your children should be more appreciative of you for doing that especially having more than one at a time.  I don't understand how a person would not trust their own parents judgement for their own grandchildren.??? it makes no sense.  I would tell them to kiss my foot and they need to make their children behaive... how old was the child who hit?

Posted 2008-11-06T06:32:17Z
 
516 helpful answers

The child who hit was 11-1/2.

Posted 2008-11-06T09:17:03Z
 
2544 helpful answers

 

 Be honest and be true to yourself.

Hi Brosen,

   I believe that what you did was the right thing.  This 11 year old child should know that what he did was wrong by letting him feel what the younger child felt .  I still believe in the saying Spare the rod and spoil the child.  When we were younger, my parents punished us when we did crazy things.  I'm glad they did.  We all turned out OK.  We were not traumatized.  The kids in this day and age are spoiled rotten.  I think that they should not get away with things.  It's just like punishing a dog immediately after it pooped in the living room.  If you waited to discipline it 2 hours later, they would not know what they did wrong.  Yes, I strongly agree in a timely punishment.

    If I were you, I would talk to the child's parents that you were just trying to discipline the child and apologize.  If they still are mad, then if I were you, I would not let them back to your house by themselves so you won't get into the same situation.

Posted 2008-11-06T12:17:43Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for brosen? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2010, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License