• Answers
  • Web
Answer 3 out of 3
 
A:

The U.S. attack on Iraq implies two ethical (or moral) considerations. On the one hand one can argue that any unprovoked ( of course this is open to question) on another country is an immoral step. On the other hand one can posit that enforcing the clauses of a peace treaty and the suspicions of nuclear armament are a cause for invasion.

What you can gain from these positions is that "ethical considerations" are always debatable as is most of human conduct.

Helpful?(3)
Rated as Best Answer

Comments About This Answer Add a comment

 
DrStrangelove (thinks this answer is Helpful)

In the case of the present War in Iraq and Afghanistan, the provocation came on 9/11/2001, a clear provocation to war: attack by an undisclosed power on another power's sovereign territory is provocation under the Geneva Accords (The Hague 2000). It then falls the victim's responsibility to discover the identity of the attacking power and prosecute war under existing international law and accords.

United Nations determined that Iraq and Afghanistan acted jointly in allowing the stateless terrorist organization, Al Qaeda, to conduct training on their territory, thereby involving them as belligerent powers under the Accords of War, signed jointly by the United States, Iraq, and Afghanistan -- among 103 other sovereign powers.

A state of war does not need to exist for us to prosecute this sort of police action, as a pacification of hostilities. However, should Congress declare war, which is very likely, then it will cease to be a limited police action and will be another Desert Storm, prosecuted to the limit of International Law.

The United Nations has, under treaty with all signatory powers, the sovereign right to direct signatories to mobilize troops and deploy without notice. Article 23 of the UN Accord contemplates the use of force and from which nations these forces may be called.

 
Comment About This Answer (or add your own answer)

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners