• Answers
  • Web

Insanity is doing things the same way and expecting different results.

Convicted of statutory rape and receiving Oscar?

Is it right to give any award to a man who has been convicted of statutory rape?

Famed movie director Roman Polanski was convicted of the statutory rape of Samantha Geimer in Judge Laurence Rittenband's Los Angeles courtroom in 1978; the crime occurred when Geimer was 13 and they were at Jack Nicholson’s house in the Hollywood Hills. During the trial, Polanski was jailed for 42 days. When it became clear that the judge wanted to "get" him, the Oscar-winning director of "Chinatown" and "Rosemary’s Baby" fled the U.S. for France and never returned.

Polanski won Best Director for the extraordinary Holocaust memoir, The Pianist in 2003.

Is it right to honor this guy after his disgusting behavior?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

4 Posted Answers
Order by

 
506 helpful answers

This is an ethical question that would have been more easily resolved years ago before the age of relativism (there is no absolute right or wrong). I personally agree that Polanski should not have been given any reward. But unfortunately the powers that be feel that art must be above the morality of the artist. There was an uproar in Israel when Berenboim against the wishes of many (including holocaust survivors) conducted a concert consisting of compositions by Wagner.

Posted 2008-05-08T08:45:18Z
 

A lot of today's very renown artists, authors and philosophers were convicted in crimes. Oscar Wilde was imprisoned for homosexuality, Egon Schiller for some moral sexual thing, Socrates was sentenced to death for corrupting the youth and so on. There are a whole bunch of contemporary musicians that wins grammys and other music awards while being convicted for drug use, DUI, sexual assault, etc.

Being an artist doesn't mean you have to live a more moral life then others. 

He got an awared for making a good movie, not for being a good person. If this was the "honorary good person prize" then I would have seen a problem with him winning, but since the movie is very good and deserve the award, I can't see a problem. 

Posted 2008-05-13T00:46:48Z
lilly was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
732 helpful answers

 

~ Snotternonsense  TurkeyEater ~

 

S.N.O.T.S., Inc.

They weren't rewarding the man for his behavior.  They were rewarding him for his directorial talent.  The man committed a crime 25 years before he received his Oscar.  Talented people are also human.  They behave badly.  Look at artists, musicians, sports figures.  All the drugs, sex, and idiocy.  We still reward them because they are providing something extraordinary, despite their stupidity.  Excellence should always be recognized.  There is so little of it in this world.

Posted 2008-06-12T00:57:55Z
 
Lee
(deleted account)

More than 100 industry leaders and prominent authors have signed a petition asking that Polanski be released from Swiss custody. I think the people have honestly forgotten what this is really about. Everyone needs to go back and read the grand jury testimony to remember how vicious this rape was. There's no excuse for forcing sex on a 13-year-old girl. But I think Polanski is a genius. He has led one of the most interesting lives of anyone in the film industry. You can read the book about his many misadventures, misfortunes, and mistakes.

Posted 2009-10-07T03:47:15Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for domino? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Amy Fisher "Long Island Lolita" sex tape

Former "Long Island Lolita" Amy Fisher is joining her husband in trying to market a sex tape, she and her husband, Louis Bellera ...
Submitted by JoeyBoy   2 years ago.
  • viewed 8971 times
Last answer posted 2 years ago by MusicIsMyHotHotSex


Q:

Condoms do NOT "protect" against MANY STD's!

Why do we continue to LIE to patients telling them they are "protected" when using cndoms , when our own CDC states that condoms ...
Submitted by laura   1 year ago.
  • viewed 314 times
Last answer posted 1 year ago by Skitch


Q:

Who are the dumbest people in Hollywood?

There was a list on entertainment secion of msn.com about the dumbest people in Hollywood. I cannot access it now but I'm ...
Submitted by AllisonG   2 years ago.
  • viewed 995 times
Last answer posted 8 months ago by Delila


Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License