• Answers
  • Web
Personalize Yedda, (And make Danny Happy)
People ask & answer about almost everything. Tell us what you're interested in... So we can personalize Yedda especially for you
I'm interested in:

Converting

Thinking about converting my religion.What do you need to do in order to become a Jew/Muslim?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

3 Posted Answers
Order by

 
73 helpful answers

Actually Judaism and Islam, although often included as two of the three large monotheist religions, are very different, and I think your choice of conversion should be based on your faith and belief more than anything else.

Probably the best way would be to make an appointment with a religious official  - both a Jew and a Muslim - and work out with both the fundamentals of each religion.   

Posted 2007-06-24T17:40:02Z
 
5 helpful answers

One must assume that anyone wishing to change his religion from what he was born into means that he finds the set of beliefs or practices inadequate for his spiritual development or for what he feels is the real meaning of living a religion.
While accepting Islam is simple the convert or revert should have more than a superficial understanding of the religion he has chosen and its obligations. Islam means to surrender one's will to God.If one declares, particularly in public and usually in Arabic, although it is not a legal necessity, with sincerity that there is no other god to be worthy of worship but Allah and Muhammad is His Messenger, he would be considered to have accepted Islam. It is a contract between the individual and God and with the community of believers.  He may also be asked to repeat certain statements to affirm his acceptance of the fundamental beliefs and practices and his willingness to abide by them to the best of his ability. As faith is so important one should not delay accepting Islam if one has spent some time considering this act. Today, considering the atmosphere, to become a Muslim will put the individual in some difficulties in certain societies and it should not be entered into lightly without having done some research. The punishment for giving up Islam after accepting it, that is apostasy, in an Islamic state has been considered to be death because although it is not mentioned in the Qur’an, therefore one should not enter into it lightly. Islam teaches that there is no compulsion in religion but those who enter into it and then give it up with the intention of creating doubt and as a means of attacking Islam must understand that it is considered an act of treason. Those unbelievers at the time of the birth of Islam used this method to cause confusion and were not sincere and it was considered an act of war. Some scholars are reassessing this punishment, which can only be carried out by an Islamic court, especially for those who have been born into Islam without ever having examined its teachings and practices and find that they can no longer adhere to its beliefs and practices in good faith. Obviously, such a person would be advised to keep private his loss of belief, unwillingness to accept all of the Islamic laws or his acceptance of another belief as preferable to Islam, especially in traditional Muslim societies. Today, in pluralistic, modern and democratic societies, family, neighbors and the general public may adopt measures that are no longer violent but clearly demonstrate their dislike of those who adopt Islam. He must understand that some of the beliefs of the faith he has chosen may contradict his previous beliefs and he must be ready to reject them in addition to fully understanding the basic beliefs and obligations of his new faith. In Islam, scholars have enumerated the Pillars of Faith and the Pillars of Islam and he should understand that while faith is the essential part of belief, there are actions that confirm this belief as well as acts of omission or commission that can negate or compromise this faith. They may be classified as small or big sins. Not to observe the obligatory acts would not take you out of Islam but to state that these acts are not obligatory or no longer suitable or to hold certain beliefs which go against the essence of Faith may put that individual automatically outside of Islam whether he expresses it publicly or holds it privately. Excommunication has been carried it by the Catholic Church as well as in Judaism and in Islam if a person has publicly expressed a belief or has acted in a way that insults Islam he may be treated as a heretic and may risk execution in a state governed by Islamic law. In addition, in such a state certain acts which may be considered in a secular state as in the personal area and may not even be  considered even sins such as fornication and adultery have whipping and stoning as a punishment. Theft is punishable by amputation and murder by capital punishment or if accepted by the victims relatives by blood money. In order to carry out such punishments, it is generally understood that such a state has done everything necessary to prevent such crimes by providing an environment that discourages such activities. Islam is a religion of belief and practice as well as a system that deals with social, political and economic spheres of life. A Muslim can live under secular rule and is not obligated to carry out these punishments as they are only applicable in an Islamic state but he must not reject their obligatory nature. Some, who identify themselves as Muslims, reject these punishments and others as no longer being applicable in modern times. Other practices such as drinking alcohol and gambling are forbidden but have no Qur’anic punishment prescribed but the government may choose a suitable one according to the circumstances.In short, it is not simply a matter of uttering a phrase or changing one’s name or even putting on a special dress but how one acts. Of course, Islam has certain standards of dress and behavior that are required and reflect the desire of the believer to conform to Islam. Our object is to please our Creator in every aspect of life and to uphold justice and mercy for everyone whether Muslim or not.I have written the above, not as a scholar, but to try to help anyone wishing to accept Islam to be aware of the importance of carefully weighing this decision and to study the many books including available sources on the Internet and contact knowledgeable Muslims so as to enter Islam wholeheartedly.
Converts infuse new blood but they must continue to learn more about their faith and be an inspiration to those who have been born Muslims but may not be living up the best that is expected.
I hope I have not gone into too much detail, but it is information that I believe anyone planning on accepting Islam to be aware of.
I am a born Muslim from converted parents. In a sense, we are converting ourselves every day to properly represent Islam and not distort it by fanaticism and extremism. Those who use Islam to justify actions of violence that go against the clear Islamic injunctions will someday have to answer for their distortions and misrepresentations. There are those who have their own agenda who also attack Islam in order to demonize Muslims for partisan political purposes or for simple missionary propaganda.
Let us compete in the marketplace with mutual tolerance, respect and love.
 
 
   
 

Posted 2007-06-25T17:09:25Z
ameer_r2 was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(4)
Rated as Best Answer
 
10 helpful answers

My reality check has bounced! Wink

Visit: Becoming Jewish

Converting to a religion - no matter what it is - means that you are forging a new path into a new life. I can only speak as to conversion to Judaism as I have done it myself.

Converting to Judaism can take anywhere from 1-5 years and involves a lot of study and work. Learning the Tanach (Jewish Scripture), Hebrew, Jewish holidays, Jewish theology, and halachah (Jewish Law) are all part of what must be done by the potential convert. After a period of study, the convert must go before a bet din (rabbinical court) and they will judge whether the person will be accepted into Judaism. In addition, males must go through circumcision (if they are already circumcised, a symbolic drop of blood will be taken) and bother males and females must immerse themselves in a mikveh (ritual bath).

Converting to Judaism is a long process and not to be taken lightly. It is better to remain a good non-Jew and follow the Noahide Laws than to convert and be a sinful Jew. Judaism believes that all the righteous of the nations have a place in the World To Come and there is no need to convert. 

Posted 2008-01-27T00:25:54Z
earthfire was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(4)
Rated as Best Answer

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for Kisha? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Islam and Education: is it Enough?

This Sunday's NYT Book Review is an all-Islam issue - reviews, essays and more dealing with Islam. Since 9/11, publishers have ...
Submitted by artists   2 years ago.
  • viewed 640 times
Last answer posted 2 years ago by grixit


Q:

Need some help please

What do i need to know about care for a muslims mail and femail thinks like the left and right hand law . Who can the muslim wonem ...
Submitted by henry   2 months ago.
  • viewed 130 times
Last answer posted 2 months ago by NJoy


Q:

Freedom of religion

So, someone wanted to start a thread about this particular topic, "Freedom of Religion." So, here it is. What does it mean to ...
Submitted by Mondabi2000   9 months ago.
  • viewed 755 times
Last answer posted 3 months ago by kid



» More...

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License