• Answers
  • Web
Originated from
AOL Search

3 Daughters

Why is my oldest daughter so hurtful and judgemental.  My oldest daughter sayes the most hurtful remarks.  Her younger sister has made some bad choices in her life.  She is now going thru an ugly divorce she has 2 boys 3 and 1 years old.  If falls on me as the Mom to help.  My oldest daughter looks on this as me favoring the grandchildren of the daughter going thru the divorce over her daughter.  I do evething possible for that not to be the case...however my oldest will call and start agruments and continue to complain about the mistakes her sister made and why I or (family) has to continually bail her out....this daughter forgets that she made her own share of mistakes...and I was there for her as well.

I get along with her mother in law, but how long this well continue I don't know, because in every argument she will say....Why do you think we ask  (Maggie) the mother in law watch our daughter and not you.  This has been said to me more then one time. (keep in mind I watched her daughter all the way up until my daughter went thru her divorce) now I'm no good enought to watch her now.  

Well this has been said to many times...this time I choose to just hang up on her.... I was brought up to help your family thru the hardtimes as well as the goodtimes....my oldest daughter has changed a lot. 

My youngest is only 14 although she is not in this mess.  She sees it hurts me which upsets her.

Why is she actng like this and why is she so hurtful.


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

6 Posted Answers
Order by

 
4619 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi, ---------- Very touching. On top of your problems you have to deal with those additional problems. Since you didn't mention a husband (to help you, to support you and to lean on him) I believe that he is not around and you have to deal with it on your own. My best advise is: Discuss it (open and deep) with your oldest daughter. Prepare, in advance, what and how you are going to say (be smart and sensetive), and tell her exactly what you feel and what you want (including what you want from her). Don't forget to mention that you love her to death, equally as all your other daughters, but she has to understand that at this specific time her sister needs more attention and more support..... Everyone loves one's fingures equally.... now assume that one fingure got a bad wound..... the entire attentin and care is now given to that fingure and it doesn't mean that the other fingures are worth less..... Finish with a big hug and a big loving kiss and tell her you need her understanding and support. I hope it works. --------- Best regards,

Posted 2008-09-01T14:46:01Z
 

Actually there is a husband we've been married 27 years, problem is he doesn't like to upset his girls....2nd this divorce of my middle daughter has been hard on all of us...her husband was phyically and verbally abusive.  So it's hard on my husband not being able to act on his feelings towards the ex-husband....he is also the type of father that sees nothing his girls do wrong...and doesn't like confrontation.

Posted 2008-09-01T22:47:12Z
 
4619 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi, ------------ Great !. Did you try to discuss it with him ? Did you try try to find out what is he palnning to do ? Did you try to get his support ? I feel that you have to make him part of the team (and not an outside player). If you manage to make him more active he might be a key factor and give a great contribution..... You have to convince him to be part of the solution (there are times when one has to be active and work hard, even if it unpleasant..... who likes confrontations ? no one..... I belive, but still there are times one has to do it). ------------ Best regards,

Posted 2008-09-02T08:31:02Z
 

My husband and I did talk, he said he realises how much it upsets me when my daughters make remarks, he sayes but you know they don't mean what they say and that we both need time to cool down.  He said we are to much alike...but he says he knows when I'm upset I shut down and don't want to talk so he feels leave me alone for a day or two then talk....he's probally correct on that part...He's a good husband he can tell when I'm upset he's answer is to just hold me and give me time.    I waited a few days then talk to my daughter and told her I knew this was hard on her as well as everyone in the family....and that I love her, her husband and daughter with all my heart.  But sometimes she needs to realize that she should think about what she sayes before she sayes it.   She will always say mom I was just upset...I didn't mean what I said...I told her weather you mean it or not...it still hurts.   She said I do want to support my sister but I just get fustrated that I feel like she doesn't listen.  I explained trust me I know I have a little sister the same way...and I'm still helping her...you will most likely have to do the same for your sister as well.    I know she loves her sisters...it's one of those cases I can say what I want about my sister, but no one else better.

Thank you for your help and advise...it was just good talking to someone about

Posted 2008-09-04T23:09:12Z
 
21 helpful answers

Lets Go Red Sox!

HI momhurt, I think your daughter is obviously acting out from a need for attention.  That is painfully obvious to me bc Ive been the daughter who acted in a similiar way when my sister got a lot of attention and I wanted and needed a portion of the attention that she was getting.  Things seemed out of balance to me.  Are things in balance in your family?  I think that its important for parents to show love to all of their children in a balanced manner.  To never favor one child even when one child may need their parents more at a given moment.  My advice, although you arent asking for it, would be to try to give your eldest attention as well as your other two daughters, I agree with OronD, make sure she knows that you love her and you want to do whatever you can to support her by doing anything you can, and reinforce that you will always be there for her.  Also let her know that what you do for her sisters is really between you and the other girls, and she shouldnt concern herself with it.  You then need to follow up with a ton of love and attention to the first daughter so she can see for herself that she really does have your unyeilding devotion as a parent.  Thats just my 2c.  Best of Luck :)

Posted 2008-09-14T03:27:25Z
 

I have never favored one child over another. I am there for all three of my children my oldest 25, middle child is 23(going thru a very bad and abusive divorce) and my youngest who has to go thru so much with her 2 oldest sisters she is only 14. My oldest is loved very much and gets a lot of attention her and I actually are in business together as realtor's. When my oldest was going thru a bad period in time I was there for her as well....now unforuntally it is her sister that is dealing with crap now. We are a very close family...but the issue that her sister is going thru has hurt this entire family no one really knows how to handle things because we have never had to go thru someone abusing one of our family members...the other thing is I think my oldest is going thru that she feels like she should be able to protect her sister and cant. My oldest has always been the one that has more or less rescued her sister...from toddler to present. My middle daughter has always been the weaker of the 3 and it's hard for all of us to see what she going thru and feel like our hands are tied. Domestic Abuse on your child and sibling is a very hard thing to handle. Thank you for your advise.

Posted 2008-09-14T12:33:31Z

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for momhurt? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

My daughter holds my grand children like hostage,to hurt me

when a mother disown her child, its sad my daughter holds my grandchildren like pawns to hurt me.and she does a good job of ...
Submitted by wejar2005   1 year ago.
  • viewed 915 times
Last answer posted 8 days ago by Bluewolfe


Q:

Steal daughter’s style?

Is it ever OK for a mother and daughter to share clothes?
Submitted by Fashion Chic   4 months ago.
  • viewed 186 times
Last answer posted 22 days ago by xoxo


Q:

I love the letter I wrote - it might knock some sense into my cuz

Last night I wrote this letter to my cuz and mailed it today. I did not want to email this letter because I think when he has the ...
Submitted by voterperson   3 days ago.
  • viewed 56 times
Last answer posted 3 days ago by Jay



» More...

Explore Related Posts in Forums

Teen Pregnancy My 14 Year Old Daughter Is Pregnant

My 14 year old daughter is pregnant by her 15 year old boyfriend. I feel he has stolen my baby away ) rosejackson replied on July 20th, 2006 Supporter Its right for you to feel so protective of your daughter father and his family, I hope you are recording the hurtful and abusive things he and his family

My best friend died monday. How long will hurt last? : depression

Ask for help or provide help with depression related issues. things. And to be the one to tell others about her death hurts. Everything just hurts. It's this sinking to disregard this. It's just a bit of a rant. I am sore and hurt and everything in between. There is nothing

Billy Joel's daughter attempts suicide (with homeopathic medication)

On the other hand, this could prove to be the one benefit of homeopathic medicine: Depressed teenagers can't thoughts go to Billy Joel, Christie Brinkley and their daughter Alexa Ray. We wish them all well “I am especially sensitive to this news about Alexa Ray Joel because I have a daughter the same age
» More...
Powered by
Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2009, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License