21 pounds in 21 days

I read about the 21 pounds in 21 days diet and it sounds a bit too drastic for me. It's probably OK if you're spending these 21 days in Martha's Vineyard under medical supervision, but doing this it at home? Isn't it dangerous?


Share Send to a friend Watch Report
 
 

24 Posted Answers
Order by

 
4691 helpful answers

Love is the battery of life....

Hi,


Yes, don't do it yourself.  It could be dangerous.  According to the statistics some 95% (I am not sure about the excat figure) of all people who start a diet will return to their original weight.  Therefor my advise: Better take a diet that goes slowly A target of 2-3 pounds a week is OK).  Above all adopt healthy eating habbits.  Make your body get used to healthy food, proper quantitives, and at the same time (e.g:  07:00 breakfast, 10:00 fruit.  13:00 Dinner.....  etc).  Sure you need a strong will.  To get a strong will all you have 2 do is think what great it will be at the end.....
Wish you all the best,
D"r D. Oron
 
137 helpful answers

It sounds like a sure thing to gaining the weight back...

Having tried more than one or two diets myself (lets be honest here, more than 10 or 20 would be more accurate :P) I can honestly say whatever comes off this fast, will getback on almost as fast, usually with interest.

I mean 95% of diets fail, and this one seems even more prone to failing than others... 

I wouldn't mind a trip to the Vineyards, I just don't want the visit to be rated by my weight only. 

 
6 helpful answers

I think it could be great!

The author (Roni) has some great ideas, and you can apply most of them at home. I think most of the people who are against it only put it down because they're afraid to try.

This is the book, and I'm seriously considering buying it for my mom.


 

 

I'm 59 and have had weight issues most of my life, including weighing over 310 lbs (at 5' 6"). I've finally stabilized my weight after years of 'practice' getting it right. 

 

Over the past 35 years I've lost 160 lbs in a 9-month period; 55 lbs in a 5-month period; 40 lbs in a 3-month period; and, lastly, 65 pounds in a 14-month period.  Guess which has been the lasting success? 

 

There is no replacement for time and relearning eating habits. The quickle diets such as the one you suggest will certainly take off weight, but the weight will return.  The weight WILL return.  And, unfortunately, it will probably return with a few additional pounds due to metabolic issues. 

 

We put on weight 'over time', so why is it we think we can take it off overnight?  Mostly because we aren't thinking -- we're reacting.  We wake up one day -- or we have an epiphany over a few days -- where we say "I've had it!  I'm done!  I'm losing this weight!  I'm going to do it!"  This sounds great and positive.  Sounds as though we've finally got our act together, right?  Sounds pretty noble, doesn't it?  

 

Wrong.  It's the same reaction that causes us to down a pound of chocolate.  It's an emotional reaction.  In the case of wanting to take weight off, it is probably an overdue emotional reaction, but it is still just that.  A reaction.  

 

You must make a decision to lose weight.  

 

That doesn't mean that you have to sit still and/or keep eating chocolate while you're getting in the right frame of mind.  At any moment, you can choose to have one bite of chocolate rather than a whole pound, or 1/2 pancake instead of a 6-stack. At any moment you can choose to eat an apple instead of a bag of chips, or choose to have a salad or vegetables rather than mashed potatoes.  At any moment, you can decide to walk around the block instead of watching another tv show.

 

Unfortunately, all of that sounds boring.  I know.  I've been there a thousand times.  But if you make a decision to go slowly and carefully, to retrain yourself, you will gain life-long rewards. 

 

Find a legitimate eating plan such as Weight Watchers.  Look up the Diabetic Association's or the American Heart Association's guidelines for eating.  Lose 1 lb a week.  Yes, I know!  That will mean it will take 21 weeks to lose those 21 pounds.  But you will have really lost them.  During those 21 weeks you will have learned a process.  You will have learned about how to manage your cravings and emotional eating issues.  You will be a smart and educated eater ... a smart, THIN, educated eater, and you'll have created building blocks that help you make good choices your entire life. 

 

Honest.

 

Good Luck.

 

Posted 2007-07-09T16:12:14Z
peamer was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

Helpful?(5)
Rated as Best Answer
 

I'm no doctor, just a normal person. But I've been following this diet for about two weeks now and have good results. As you probably know, it involves fasting and drinking liquid nutrient drinks or soup only. I haven't eaten solid foods in 10 days, and I have to admit I feel great and don't have cravings. I posted a bit about it on a blog if you want to check it out:

Martha's Vineyard Detox Diet
 
19 helpful answers

Great information on health, diet, and exercise: www.mattmetzgar.com 

 

 

Don't waste your time with this.  Seriously.  It's a nice fantasy and all, but the reality is it takes time and effort to lose weight.

If there was an easy way to lose weight, 2/3 of adults would not be overweight/obese right now.

Posted 2007-07-11T17:18:58Z
MattMetzgar was invited by Yedda to answer this question.

 
2 helpful answers

21 pounds in 21 days is a recipe for muscle loss.

 
12 helpful answers

A pound a week is a realistic goal to lose fat.  Anything more and you might lose muscle.

Sign in to participate

Got an answer for crocodile? Would you like to comment on the posted answers, or vote for the one which you think is the best?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

Explore Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:


Q:

Hallelujah Diet, Is it a Good Diet?

I heard about the Hallelujah Diet, but wanted to fully understand. This is a diet based on a Biblical verse in Genesis (1:29) and ...
Submitted by Kimmie   2 years ago.
  • viewed 811 times
Last answer posted 1 year ago by Imran


Q:

Does a popcorn diet really work?

Does a popcorn diet really work?
Submitted by fish   3 years ago.
  • viewed 11225 times
Last answer posted 15 days ago by zen


Q:

Fucoxanthin good or bad diets

fucoxanthin good or bad diets
Submitted by floo   1 year ago.
  • viewed 163 times
Last answer posted 13 days ago by Wealthhero
Asked about "Abs Diet - AOL Health"



» More...

Feed - Subscribe to changes to this Q&A Blog
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Answers
  • Web
Copyright © 2006-2010, Yedda Inc. and respective copyright owners · CC License